Please rate my essay! Is it good or bad?

I am applying to GOOD schools, including some ivies, so I was wondering how my essay was. I don’t think it’s that great, but what do you guys think?

This essay addresses the first prompt of the Commonapp.

Wiping the sweat off my brow, I stepped out of the car, my nerves tingling with anticipation. “This is it,” I said to myself. I was nervous, of course, but I knew that I had trained long and hard to get here, and I deserved it. All of those hours slaving away on the sweaty blue mats were finally culminating into what would soon be a single moment of glory; I was about to become a black belt.
I had begun karate lessons at the age of seven, and I had enjoyed the grace and elegance of the sport from the beginning. A combination of floridity and force, each punch and kick from the higher belts made me yearn for the next level. I often daydreamed about the day when I could roundhouse above my head and smash the punching bags backwards into the wall. As I went from yellow belt to green belt, and then from green belt to purple belt, I saw myself stepping ever-closer to what I sought.
In the middle of each of our everyday lessons, the instructor would sit down with us and tell us stories and repeat proverbs in order to attempt to instill a sense of righteousness, honor and morality into us. I often would only half-hear the advice because I was so eager to get back onto the mats, but as the years progressed, I developed a deep sense of what was right, and often felt great waves of guilt when I told even the smallest lies.<br>
Feeling all of my past experiences pushing me forward into the building, I stepped in and walked slowly over to where the rest of the soon to be black belts stood. We all sat down and the ceremony began. The head of the school, a sixth-degree black belt, stood up and began to call out names. I sat in a state of absolute suspense, waiting for him to entice me forward. When I heard “NAME REMOVED,” my heart came close to stopping. Stumbling forward with a half-grin on my face amidst heavy clapping from the audience, I gazed at my instructor’s face as he tied the belt around my waist. I was finally a black belt. The realization of the enormity of the situation suddenly struck me as I sat back down among the other ecstatic students. I could now instruct; I was no longer purely a student.
The ceremony wrapped up and everyone else quietly chattered as they walked towards the exit. Receiving a hug from my mom and a look of approval from my dad, we promptly walked into the night air. I can’t remember if it was cold; my accomplishment surged the heat of pride throughout my body.

<p>This is a very good story that captivated the reader's attention. However, the essay seems to lack perspective. I think that colleges also want to know about what you have learned from this experience. I do not see much of that in this essay. However, you do have a wonderful start. I think that, with a little work, this essay could be great. When you finish writing it, post it up, and, I'll be happy to critique it.</p>

<p>This is quite good, but needs another edit. For Ivy, the quality in the writing is not there. I'll offer some suggestions.</p>

<p>I find the opening paragraph boring. Mostly because I don't really know what you are talking about or where you are going with this. I read it impatiently, waiting to get to the meat of the story. I think you'd be stronger removing this or putting it later, in chron order. The story gets interesting to me with your second paragraph.</p>

<p>Stay away from passive voice. Your write "I had begun karate lessions... I had enjoyed..."--just say you started or began. You enjoy...etc.</p>

<p>I'd try to remove some cliched expressions and attempt something more in your own voice. I don't like this sentence--"Stumbling forward with a half-grin on my face amidst heavy clapping . Do you ever say "amidst"? "I gazed at my instructor’s face"--do you evey say gaze? These words don't have a natural quality. "The realization of the enormity of the situation" this is trite and chiche.</p>

<p>floridity-\Flo<em>rid"i</em>ty\, n.
The quality of being florid; floridness</p>

<p>florid-elaborately or excessively ornamented</p>

<p>Please take all suggestions with a grain of salt. I'm not a admissions officer or qualified in any way, so only change what you agree with.</p>

<p>very good. I love the 1st paragraph. Great hook! "I stepped out of the car" seems misleading though. I thought you were a racecar driver or something :&lt;/p>

<p>thank you everyone! your advice is much appreciated. Of course, more opinions never hurt anyone, so if you have any advice and you're lurking in the shadows, please come forward! :]</p>