Recommendation Question

I’m currently choosing between two teachers to ask for a college rec from (I already have another teacher- my English teacher- who for sure will do it). One of them is my APUS teacher- we know each other extremely well and I’m one of the best students in the class. However, I’ve often heard people saying you should also have a STEM teacher write a rec (I’m currently undecided about a future major, but am considering computer science and English). I guess I could ask my math teacher (will be generic) or my Physics teacher (I’m not the best student in the class, but he’s known me because of a club I’m captain of, so I suppose he could speak to that). Who should I choose? Or should I send my APUS teacher in as an additional rec? Thank you!