<p>I am sure it doesn't hurt to be 1 or 2 --my point is that while a percent of the class is 1 or 2, most 1 or 2 students are rejected. On the other hand, virtually all non-hooked acceptees are distinguished in that other category of special creativity, talent or unique academic ability. THAT is the special factor that determines admissions, THAT is the tipping point, not being 1 or 2. To tell a student who is #10 but actually accomplished in a unique or creative way to forget it is ...misleading. Yes all things being equal it IS better to be #1 --but it still is not the most important thing. I am saying that your emphasis is wrong. This is my opinion given my personal experience with Brown.</p>