Submit supplement about Econ or Sports Camp?

I have made two essays for my vandy supplement, one about being the president of the investment club at my school and one about being a summer camp counselor. I am majoring in econ so would it look better to submit the econ essay or the other one? Or does it not matter? My summer camp counselor essay is really charming but i just wonder whether they would like to see my expansion on an extracurricular that is very similar to my major. Thank you!

go with charming if it reflects who you are…Better than what you think they want. You gotta be you

Choose the stronger essay. I don’t think adcoms care at all about what major you put down. 50% of freshmen come in saying that they’re premed (doesn’t last long) so it’s obvious that the committee doesn’t put a whole lot of faith into what you say you’re majoring in.