The most Hands-on engineering degree

<p>I am a parent, of a HS junior son. Basically he loves pulling apart thing and is very hands on with electronics, computers, just about any thing that does something.</p>

<p>Good at software but does not want to go into CS.</p>

<p>Does this mean he has an aptitude to go into Mechanical Engineering?? We had never even considered this till now because we do not have any engineers around.</p>

<p>He is not a natural at Math (does one have to be?), but he is hardworking and likes to see the practical side of things to understand the concepts. Right now in Pre-Calc and AP Physics B.
Not acing but not hating. Has a B+ in a tough school.</p>

<p>Hates English definitely.</p>

<p>He wants to be a teacher and is good with kids, caring and understanding. I am not sure what his calling is? Can he go undecided somewhere and then figure it out? But can he do that if he went into a school of education.</p>

<p>What courses do Mech Engineers take? He likes Physics but he likes it more for the Lab part.</p>

<p>Sorry I am all over the map here!! Just need some pointers from the Engineers. Thanks.</p>

<p>

He’ll fit right in!</p>

<p>Lol!! Thats a good one!!</p>

<p>Mech E takes statics, dynamics (both have physics based concepts), thermodynamics and fluids, and some machine design type classes. I wouldn’t say it’s hands on really. There’s some labs, but I havent done any real tinkering on engines and things, but maybe that’s more at the undergrad level than grad school. I did my undergrad in Naval Architecture and absolutely loved it. I did all kinds of hands on labs in the tow tanks and designed all sorts of ship models. Not many schools have it though, but it’s a great field.</p>

<p>In general, engineering at the baccalaureate level is not really that hands-on. As navyasw02 said, there are some labs and projects, but the lion’s share of the time is spent doing things that are much more theoretical. Hands-on stuff is definitely in the realm of what you can do as an engineer, but it is far from a given in any particular flavor of engineering. The other options that are for sure more hands-on are either engineering technology (more hands-on, less theoretical) or going on to get a research-based graduate degree, especially if it is on the experimental side of things (much more theoretical, more hands-on by necessity).</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I’d say his calling is to be a teacher.</p>

<p>He should instead consider becoming a technician. </p>

<p>You can always volunteer to help in local schools. For example, become a mentor in FIRST Robotics - lol.</p>

<p>Consider aerospace. Planes and space systems are darn cool. Electrical and computer engineering <em>may</em> require a lot of hands-on stuff, but it may be a lot of fancy blue-printing and theoretical R&D work.</p>

<p>Consider an engineering technology degree instead, although that limits the types of jobs you can do.</p>

<p>Thanks All!!</p>

<p>Chuck19 - As I already said in my opening post that he ‘wants to’ be a teacher, I am fully supportive of that.</p>

<p>Reading some posts on the Engineering forum, wondering if there should be any Plan B type scenario, especially since he is still in HS.</p>

<p>Looking at his strengths and weakness it seems that he could have more options especially since he likes machines. Going into Teaching will be all consuming and little chance to change tracks later??</p>

<p>Oh gosh, don’t go into teaching. There are already too many teachers. It’s all politics and being a glorified baby-sitter these days, not much actual teaching anymore.</p>

<p>There are too many teachers but a real dearth of GOOD teachers; especially in math and science.</p>

<p>^^ I agree. He is a kind soul and has been a counselor (much loved) at our school summer camp last 2 years and thats how he ‘felt’ he could be a good teacher. But I don’t think he has thought it through completely.</p>

<p>Aerospace sounds interesting…he has shown interest in that field, but the Math? Do you have to love Math in order to be in Engineering? He does not hate math, but takes time in ‘getting it’.</p>

<p>What is Engineering Technology?</p>

<p>Actually there are loads of people who would make good teachers. But they are either turned away by the hoops you have to jump through to get a piece of paper from the government saying you are <em>allowed</em> to teach in the first place in this free country of ours, or they leave the field after realizing there are no rewards for being a good teacher and no punishments for being a bad one.</p>

<p>Well, all engineering majors require multivariable calculus at a bare minimum, he will also take a differential equations class, and probably a statistics class, he may also have to take a linear algebra class, discrete mathematical structures class, etc. But he may not, depends on his major. I’m a physics and compE major, I have to take half the math classes a full-on mathematics major takes, and what math major classes I don’t take I’ll probably study the material anyway in my physics and engineering classes.</p>

<p>Regardless of what engineering branch he goes into, basic competence in multivariable calculus and differential equations is a must to get through school. Once he’s out of school, he may find he only uses a fraction of the math he learned in any job he got. Virtually every problem he’ll have to solve in all his engineering classes are word problems in math and science.</p>

<p>My first attempt at college, years ago, I was turned off by all of the math. I had to grow up and mature and develop an interest in math which stemmed from my growing interest in physics and science. Until you get to calculus and understand its uses in science, it’s hard to get excited about math. Up to then, math seems to be all about arithmetic and algebra and word problems about moving trains and buying things on sale, etc.</p>

<p>Engineering technology, NOT TO BE CONFUSED WITH BONA FIDE ENGINEERING, is another type of undergrad degree which prepares you for a job as a technologist. You may work in quality assurance, testing machines, servicing and programming machines, etc. Think of engineering as being a doctor, and engineering technology as being a nurse. The division of labor is similar. It’s a growing field, and a lot of engineering technology majors are getting jobs as engineers (I’m talking introductory level engineering positions, not head of R&D at Intel). It’s not a bad degree, so long as you understand the limits of what you’re getting into.</p>

<p>Here is what engineering technology doesn’t prepare you for:</p>

<p>–the higher math necessary for many engineering positions, especially research and development positions
–the heavier theoretical foundations in science necessary for many engineering positions</p>

<p>ET has almost all of its emphasis on existing technology. A job in EET, electrial engineering technology, would get you a job programming and testing the embedded systems on a big machine or working on the electrical system of a big building. But an actual engineering major is the one who designed the microchips and the manufacturing machinery where the circuits were fabricated.</p>

<p>If you go to Devry, for example, you’ll study ET, not bona fide engineering. It doesn’t hurt to call up some of the companies your son is interested in working for, asking to speak to somebody in HR about the sort of jobs they do and the sort of people they hire, and ask what type of educational background is adequate.</p>

<p>There are a number of schools with Engineering technology degrees. Wentworth is an example of one school
[Wentworth</a> Institute of Technology: Prospective Students > Academics > Overview](<a href=“http://www.wit.edu/prospective/academics/overview.html]Wentworth”>http://www.wit.edu/prospective/academics/overview.html)</p>

<p>Thank you Both!! Very Helpful indeed. He is liking Physics so far but gets confused sometimes, its only been a month into AP Physics B.</p>