<p>Wally, you say that admissions officers who say flat out that they read every application and every piece and the importance of those pieces are "biased"? Why do you think they even ask for essays and recs if they do not matter? Why do they even ask for transcripts, GPA, rank, and SATs? You say it is ALL based on the audition. Did you realize that at some schools, one must be admitted first to the college before even being invited to audition? Then at other schools, after the auditors have a pile of students they are interested in, the admissions committee reviews the applicants and chooses who meets the other criteria for admissions? Do you realize that some BFA programs require ADDITIONAL essays and other materials beyond the required applications for regular applicants? Do you realize that BFA programs that exist within a university or college (unlike Juilliard, UArts, BOCO and more stand alone conservatories), require admissions to the college and in fact, SOME BFA programs exist at universities that range from moderate to very selective? (some don't, however) Do you realize that there is a percentage which varies from school to school (could be as little as 10% at CMU to as much as 50% at NYU/Tisch) of the admissions decision that is NOT the audition? And for that percentage of the admissions decision, there are MORE students who have the stats to get in academically (and have passed the audition) than slots available? And in that case, do you realize that other factors are part of that percentage of the decision....recommendations, extracurriculars, personal traits, essays, etc. ? This is basic Admissions 101. </p>
<p>BFA programs are highly competitive. I do not know which ones are on your D's list. Perhaps she is applying to schools that are stand alone conservatories....Juilliard, NCSA and others and the academic review isn't as big of a factor. Is she applying to UCLA? UMich? Tisch? Syracuse? USC? BU? CMU? FSU? Emerson? I can tell you that at many of these schools, this stuff WILL matter. It won't get you in, but if you don't have it on TOP of the audition, good luck. There are far more academically qualified AND talented kids than slots available. Kids who I know who now attend the TOP BFA programs in the land, as well as kids who have won National awards, state awards and so on, did not get into every BFA program on their list and they were obviously "good enough" as they are now attending top programs (and in some cases have won top awards in the field). So, when schools individually do not take every kid who is capable to do their program, you have a situation where everything counts. Sure, a highly talented kid will get into somewhere, but nobody can count on getting into them all (or which specific ones) for sure. Every poster here has supported these notions though it seems you discount it (saying I'm suggesting essays are important to garner services...as if that is the main thing I even do, or ALL4FSU is biased as she works in the BFA department). I cannot imagine heeding your advice to slack off or assume that the application was NOT read. Talk to any admissions officer, any college admissions counselor, or many who have been through the process (I know quite a number of very talented kids who got rejected at BFA schools where the academics/application does matter but were able to get into a stand alone convervatory or perhaps a BFA that exists in a very NON selective college) and you will learn that you are mistaken, particularly at competitive and selective colleges. </p>
<p>I already told you that I can tell that my own child's essays were read by the nature of some scholarships and honors/scholars she received and while she didn't even KNOW these awards and money were possible when she applied and did her application to the best of her efforts without any of this in mind, it is apparent that lots of what was revealed in essays and recs contributed to her being chosen to receive these things. I have since read the criteria for selection and often it has included artistic talent, academics, and leadership. Leadership can't be shown in the SAT scores, transcript, or audition. It sure can on the Activity Resume, recommendations, and essays.</p>
<p>Another example that doesn't apply to others' situations specifically, but is an example of these materials being read, is that my D was an early graduate (after her junior yr. of HS) and early graduates' applications are scrutinized more than regular applicants (a known fact in college admissions) and my daughter also wrote a supplementary statement (beyond her required essays) as to her rationale for early graduation and her readiness and I know that her teacher recs and guidance counselor reports also commented on this issue. These HAD to have been read because adcoms take extra care in evaluating the applications of early graduates. That is an example but other kids also have other things in their paper work. </p>
<p>By the way, applicants to UMich's BFA in MT program have to send an extensive repertoire document in with the applications. The adcom there said they examine every essay, the rigor of the curriculum, stats, and these extra artitistic documents and recs to decide who to invite to audition. I don't think she had any reason to make that up.</p>
<p>Further, many BFA programs are in colleges where the BFA student will have to take some liberal arts courses and if the college is a selective one, the admissions office will want the student to be able to be successful in these courses. As well, BFA programs themselves are intensive and hard core. It takes a certain kind of student to hack them, not ONLY talent. I have met with some kids who I do not believe could handle the rigors of a BFA program by the nature of the kind of student that they are. BFA programs are admitting people, not JUST how well they act or sing. </p>
<p>Now, you are validating that when there is a "tie" between some equally talented candidates for a selective BFA, that the application itself may make a difference. So, if that is true (and it is), do you honestly believe when there are ten slots available (just an example....but it is not the number so much, but more the admit rate of between 2-9% at most top BFAs, for MT anyway), that there are only TEN applicants who they LOVED at the audition and feel are at the level and have the potential to be in their program? Did you think that this so called "tie" is unusual or only between TWO candidates? Hardly! I doubt that there are only ten kids (or how many slots are open) a program really want in all of the auditions. </p>
<p>I can tell you that at CMU (and others of course) there is a waitlist. They are interested in the kids on the waitlist if not all the offered slots are taken in their yield. My D was on the priority waitlist at CMU for Acting. She has a friend in CMU's BFA for MT who got in off the waitlist another year. The kids on the waitlist had to pass muster if there was room depending on yield. They are willing to accept them if there is room, in other words. So, there were more than 10 (Or whatever the number may be depending on the school) who they are interested in, but can only take ten. Think about it.</p>
<p>Again, I don't know your D's list and her programs may be stand alone conservatories or exist in much less selective universities or colleges (outside the BFA part). I have no idea why you think an admissions officer is biased in telling you this, a college counselor, current BFA students and parents of current BFA students would have any reason to steer you wrong about this. Perhaps you know something we don't? </p>
<p>Further, I believe you have been asked to refrain from commenting on others' posting styles and stick to the ideas. If you don't like certain posts, feel free, as you have, to not read them. I, as well as others, volunteer to help and share what we know for those going through the process. Many of us are parents or students who have been through it already. Some of us are even trained in this field. Some even work at these college programs. You have posed some questions and people are volunteering to answer them to HELP. If you don't care for my posts or the posts of others, ignore them, but please refrain from discussing the poster or his/her writing style, spelling or word count. CC has no rules about spelling or word count. They do have rules about courtesy, personal attacks, and posting about the personal qualities of other posters. Thank you.</p>