Unconventional College Experience and Med School?

Hi everyone!! So this is not a “what are my chances” forum… it’s more of a “do you have any advice on how to spin my story so that I can improve my chances” thread.

I’m a junior at a very reputable undergraduate institution- typically, 80% of our students who will apply to medical school will get into at least one medical school. I have around a 3.8 GPA… not sure my science GPA but probably similar. Also, forgot to mention I’m majoring in bio. Haven’t taken the MCAT yet but going to do a lot of prep and hoping for at least an average score. My ECs include: D1 varsity athlete for first two years (ended up quitting because felt the team had an unhealthy atmosphere and was no longer a good fit for me), now a volunteer EMT and freshmen retreat leader. Have a held a couple of interesting internships that tie into my long-term interests.

Basically, why I am writing this is because of the “unconventional” aspects of my application. Due to health issues (i.e. mental illness) I took two medical leave’s of absence from school. I also had one “bad” semester in which I got a lower GPA (it was still a decent GPA… it was just lower than my normal perfect grades… i.e. around a 3.3 compared to usually a 3.9+). During this bad semester I was also still playing my D1 sport and was dealing with a concussion I sustained while playing this sport. On top of this, one semester, I withdrew from my classes to go on a medical leave. Just to clarify, I didn’t withdraw because I was doing poorly, I withdrew because of my health.

I’m just wondering how I can best spin this to medical schools? Should I write my personal statement about my unique experiences that will make me a more well-rounded and empathetic physician? Or should I try to gloss over it? Should I reveal the fact that I struggled with mental illness or chalk up my medical leaves to something less stigmatized? I firmly believe that these experiences will make me a better physician and a better medical student. I’ve heard stats that 50-70% of med students struggle with mental health issues… I feel that it is better to learn how to deal with it and cope before med school rather than first confronting it during med school. Unfortunately, I am aware that there is a lot of stigma around these issues in the medical community and that admissions departments may write me off about it.

Any advice for me?? Anyone who has gotten into med school after struggling with health during undergrad?? Thank you SO much for reading my annoyingly long post and have a great day :).

Personal statements are to answer the “Why Medicine?” question. If you feel there is something unique & special about your particular mental health struggles that inspired you to pursue medicine, then you can use it as part of your PS. I wouldn’t make it the centerpiece of your PS, though. Tread cautiously. However, under no circumstances should you use your mental health issues to explain a poor academic performance at any time. Adcomms hate excuses and no matter how you phrase it, it will come off as an excuse.

You may want to consider saving any discussion your mental health struggles for secondaries to address “adversity overcome” questions.

You will be asked on secondaries about any and all interruptions in your academic history–so you will have to explain your LOA. Additionally, you need to be prepared to answer questions about the reasons for your LOA during interviews since it will be asked about.

Sorry but this isn’t true. Not even close. According to multiple studies, the incidence of moderate to severe depression among med student ranges from 14 to 30% (I can provide citations if you wish to read the papers), depending on the particular study, its methodology and the year in med school of the respondents. Depression is a serious issue for med students (and even more so for medical residents), but extent of the problem isn’t anywhere even close to the percentages you so blithely completely and totally just made-up.

@WayOutWestMom Thanks for your input! Didn’t make it up… must have read an erroneous statistic.Obviously wouldn’t want to make excuses (especially since I have a 3.8 GPA)… but I actually think the one bad semester is a lot more due to the concussion. Has a huge effect on academic performance.

Unless AMCAS has added a prompt directing the content of the personal statement, I don’t agree that you’re limited to just “why medicine”. A short statement that hits upon the troublesome semester is reasonable if you can fit it in. Given that not every school puts out secondaries, it may be your only way to address the blip when they are deciding on interview invitations.

No matter what, address it head on during your interviews.

@Bigredmed

AMCAS has added a prompt for the personal statement.