Which would you choose and why?
With respect to academic reputation, there is not much of a difference. At that point, it comes down to your own personal preference or finances. I have visited each school with my kids and liked Tulane’s campus better and they leave an impression you that they pride themselves in faculty/student relationships and advisement. Neither or my kids chose Tulane or Miami, but one had a clear preference for Tulane and it made his final list.
Out of curiosity, which way are you leaning?