I think that both crime and school quality are problems in Springfield.
Earlier in the thread, people were asking about moving to new communities where they didn’t know people. People to make friends at transitional junctures – start college, start of graduate school, first job, first child, first child goes to preschool, first child goes to elementary school, etc. We have friends from all of those points. We noticed that we made many fewer friends when our second child was born, started preschool, started school etc. because those weren’t the same kind of points of transition and we probably weren’t as open to new friends at that point.
More recently, ShawWife was clothes shopping – an activity she rarely does – and struck up a conversation with a very interesting woman who had just moved to our area for a pretty interesting and high-powered job. She wanted to become ShawWife’s friend and suggested getting together. ShawWife just said her life was too full (I’m sure in a gracious way). When she got back, she described this to me and I said it would have been nice (and generous, which is ShawWife’s hallmark) to invite her over and introduce her to other folks. ShawWife said, “Yeah. I should have done that. But I didn’t take her contact information so I have no way of getting in touch with her now.”)
A couple of other stories. One of our financial advisors moved to San Diego with her husband a number of years ago. She’s charming and intelligent. They love San Diego but they had not succeeded in making a new community of friends. [This was before the Pandemic]. They said everyone they met was pleasant on the surface but somehow it didn’t go any deeper.
I don’t know if there are regional differences in how one deals with strangers and how one makes friends. My sense is that in New England and NY/NJ, people are gruffer on the surface, but when you penetrate the surface, there is the potential for depth. My limited experience in Texas was that people were alway friendly and you couldn’t tell anything from their behavior (did they like you, hate you, etc.), especially women. Male friendships seemed to get formed around activities (fishing, hunting, football). In the Bay Area, there was superficiality but it was relatively easy to go a little deeper. Not sure about Southern California or if my experiences generalize in any way.
My in-laws bought a house on Sanibel Island with the intention of retiring there. They were conscious about cultivating a community so that when they made the move (5 or 6 months a year), they would have friends. They joined the local synagogue and made friends there and were actively socialized with neighbors etc. Over the years, they made a very nice community and even now when it is only my MIL (who is much less gregarious than her husband, who has been deceased for 20 years), neighbors and others are always looking out for her.
More generally, a wise friend said that for mental health, most people need 1) community, 2) meaning and 3) structure. Moving to a new place, it is probably worth investing energy in all three.