I certainly didn’t say that - I excluded it because it’s a science-oriented school and “one of the best,” as I noted in my comment. A student who didn’t want to be in a science-oriented college might not enjoy Mudd. The point of my comment is that the science education is likely to be pretty similar at most general types of top liberal arts colleges.
I’m also wary of using PhD outcomes as a measure of the department’s science education/quality. Some colleges just attract the kinds of students who don’t necessarily want to continue onto academic study and research careers, and some colleges may emphasize practical education or careers directly after the bachelor’s.