Why did all of you write the same essay (why this school/major)?

Not to hijack the thread, but what I think is wrong with the vast majority of the college essays is that the applicant comes off as the callow, self-centered, over-achieving, spoiled and immature teenager that they are. Seriously, most of them sound like they were written by the younger versions of Bond villains.

What’s missing is a deeper understanding of the world outside of their direct experience, and a mature understanding of how they, and their plans / dreams / ambitions, fit into it. Admittedly, it’s a vague sort of standard, but it is something that you definitely recognize when you see it, and that’s the thing that can really make the difference. The rest is just typing, as Truman Capote said.

Again, sorry for this being off topic, and a bit of a rant, and also a hijack.

And I thought I was being a curmudgeon! :smiley:

LOL, no one out-curmudgeons me!


[QUOTE=""]

:slight_smile:

[/QUOTE]

I think what is getting lost in this post, and others that the OP has written on essay writing, is the importance of the narrative voice. It is clear from the responses that many do not understand that the example essay is not about how to write a great essay on “Why CMU”, but how to write a good naritive essay in general.

To many times students are being told “show, don’t tell!” But most have never been taught how to write a good naritive essay, or an essay that "shows ". It is unfortunate that college admissions look for this type of writing, but high schools tend to avoid teaching anything other than prep for AP language and AP literature tests. There is a disconnect.

@digmedia I have seen many of your advice posts, and while you do mention voice, you don’t really delve deeply into the topic. I think students (and the volunteers who read their work) would benefit greatly from more information.

My D16 answered one of those essay in the same run of the mill manner that you decry, but ended it with something along the lines of “maybe I can even learn to play the bagpipes.”. Might have worked, she was accepted.

Agree you have throw in something to make it memorable.

Thanks @digmedia , I needed this.
Still some schools have 100-word maximums to these kinds of essays, I don’t see how one can avoid triteness there.

Also some prompts ask directly “how are you going to take advantage of the resources at this University” Specifically I’m talking about Northwestern, so I don’t see how to avoid that without looking like you didn’t answer every part of the prompt, which nearly everyone agrees that you should do. I think this goes back to post #6

@LKnomad - There is a fairly simple way to test your essay to see if it is in your voice: Read it out loud to someone. Does it sound like you talking or are you stumbling over words you would never yourself use? Does it flow smoothly or are you forcing formality? For example, so many students use the word “plethora,” but would you really say to another person, “I have had a plethora of opportunities to demonstrate how I aspire to achieve…”

As for "showing, not telling"I advise students to think of most obvious example of showing vs telling a story is a movie script. It draws us into a story, and makes us love the main character in the story. The “secret recipe” for doing this is in the ingredients and structure of the screenplay.

Ingredient #1: The Goal - You will notice that there is always something at stake in a movie, whether it’s saving the world, finding someone to love, going after something other people want, or going after something the main character wants. It’s that thing at stake that will drive the story forward.

Ingredient #2: The Conflict -Only in a boring (and short) movie would the main character attain the goal right away. It doesn’t happen immediately because there is always an element of conflict or nemesis or transformation. People or circumstances or events always get in the way of attaining the goal, and the battle to overcome that person or thing or event is what draws us into the story as the transformation occurs.

Ingredient #3: The Flaw - In the best films, the main character has an issue, a problem, a character flaw, a fear, a disability, or a burden that will get in the way of attaining the goal. The film needs to show how the conflict or nemesis in the film can only be overcome by the main character transforming and conquering his or her issue (or problem or character flaw or fear or disability or burden) and attain the goal.

Ingredient #4: The Transformation (Character Development) - By overcoming his or her own issues to resolve the overall conflict or defeat the nemesis, the hero or heroine emerges as a stronger person. There is a story arc (character development) in place. The concept of change – and change for the better – is important in our story telling.

Simple example: Early in a film you might get a glimpse of our hero’s fear of snakes. Now let’s say that the situation that presents the conflict is for our hero to be trapped in an Egyptian tomb. The quest is to find the way out and escape. But the twist is that when he figures out just how to go about doing that, he finds the way is blocked with snakes (“Snakes! It has to be snakes!”). So he has to overcome his fear (and thus change and become a stronger person) to escape his situation. While it seems like the main plot is to escape from the tomb, overcoming his fear is the really the HEART of the screenplay and what makes us more emotionally involved with the character.

All of this applies as well to essays. The best personal statements are those in which you are asked to explain how you’ve overcome a conflict or obstacle to achieve something. (more in next post)

Here’s an example of using a cinematic approach to “Why this major?” (In this case, the major is Acting.) Some of the “ingredients” are subtle, but they are there.

Notice how much more effective this essay is than one that starts with “I want to major in Acting because…”

(((Apologies to those who have seen this from me before)))

@Ksty1098 - Obviously the prompt questions must be answered.

The acting one is fantastic!, but the writer couldn’t have done the same with a 100-word maximum.

@digmedia all great advice, but for a student who does not have experience with narrative writing, it is all VERY overwhelming. It is also stressful to have to learn a new writing style during college app season.

One piece of advice for helping students that I heard at a conference recently, was having a student start with something simple such as taking 30 minutes to write about their experience this morning - narrating the story of waking up, getting out of bed, eating breakfast, getting ready for school. It is often the little stories, not the overly dramatic ones, that make good essays.

My son has been able to write some dynamite narative essays so far. He told me that he starts each essay by reading something written (well) in the narative voice so he can remember to change from academic writing to story telling. He says that narrative writing does not come naturally so he needs a reminder.

@LKnomad - Good points and good advice.

<<<it is="" often="" the="" little="" stories,="" not="" overly="" dramatic="" ones,="" that="" make="" good="" essays.="">>>

I couldn’t agree more.

First off, most Why Us don’t allow for so much wording. (Same for Why This Major.) Second, for either, adcoms don’t want to be lulled into a tale, smell the night jasmine. For the Why Us, they want to very quickly get a read on whether you understand how you match. That’s not naming profs or how excited you are they have study abroad (duh,) or the city or the ivy growing on the walls. And the more competitive the college, the more the kiss of death is, as someone implied, going generic. Or focusing on your career goals or this dilly: you’re a top school and I want to go to a top school. Think.

If you do know the college well, if you’re thinking, Why Us should be a piece of cake. Some kids can describe the atmosphere or a positive incident, some describe how they can combine interests, some match their values. It goes on.

As for Why this Major, show a little forethought. Wanna know how many kids want STEM so they can save the world? (Or how many want engineering but don’t seem to have the foggiest notion what it does?) Or how many decided in kindergarten that they wanted to be docs, as if the longer the dream, the more valid?

My daughter wrote about her two hour experience cleaning out a closet. She wrote about how it made her appreciate history. It worked for her- she was accepted to 3 out of the 4 selective schools she applied to.

Perhaps the issue is the prompt lends itself to insincerity? Imagine how some of the truthful responses would go over? “Because my Mom wants me to…because I am in the top quartile and I need merit aid…CC said I need safety schools…my friends go there…because I am shot gunning…because of the ranking/name…because I want to live where your school is located…because I don’t have the stats for schools I am really interested in…because you meet full need…because I would always regret it if I didn’t try to get into your school…”

@lookingforward - <<<if you="" do="" know="" the="" college="" well,="" if="" you’re="" thinking,="" why="" us="" should="" be="" a="" piece="" of="" cake.="" some="" kids="" can="" describe="" atmosphere="" or="" positive="" incident,="" how="" they="" combine="" interests,="" match="" their="" values.="" it="" goes="" on.="">>> Perfectly said!

@twogirls - <<>> Love it!!

@twogirls - <<>>
That’s awesome and interesting! I’d think that great essays would be about “phenomenal” things like starting a charitable program or overcoming a life obstacle. =D>

@twogirls - <<>>
Congratulations and kudos to her!:smiley: =D>

@TheCollegeGirl -

BY FAR (BY A MILE) the best essay ever submitted to me was one where a student described her meeting a great guy and the hour or so afterwards! By far the best. BY FAR. It showed her to be not only a great writer, but it gave an incredible insight into who she was. It also sent me to the internet to look up a reference she made. She got accepted into every elite college she applied to, except Yale.