@Rngrvr This is a no-brainer. ND first by a long shot. It is too bad Gettysburg College is not an option.
You are building a resume so build it well.
Notre Dame is among the most selective schools in the USA where the top 2 - 3% of all students attend. Not to mention the campus, sports, school spirit, etc
Richmond is a fine school as well. Hobart would be third.
Don’t listen to anyone that comments on ND being Catholic, it doesn’t matter.