Would I be stupid for turning down the chance to do my year abroad at Notre Dame compared to northea

I assume that Georgetown isn’t on the list - I can’t imagine the OP somehow forgot to mention it, given that it would meet all his/her criteria. The study abroad option clearly states that the availability of places varies from year to year, so it is likely that Georgetown is simply not available to this student (but if I’m wrong, it would be the obvious choice).