Your examples of Uninformed/Informed first choices in College Selection?

"Well, if you look at the data, you would see that UChicago is not a good place for a minority to be a premed. "

I do not agree the data implies this, but even if it did - it is simply not relevant for most applicants. The majority of applicants are not AA premeds so giving your opinion as if those unique circumstances apply to every applicant is unhelpful at best, harmful at worst. There are literally millions of non - AA, non premed applicants out there and they have different criteria than the ones you first manufacture and then keep repeating in multiple threads. Imposing your judgment and criteria on other applicants is uninformed.