<p>I think the fact that the idea of a "college town" does not mean the same thing for all people sums up this discussion nicely. </p>
<p>For example, I don't consider Philadelphia or New York a "college town". There are plenty of great colleges in both cities, but they aren't really dominated by students, faculty, and university employees. </p>
<p>On the contrary, as a Chicago resident I do consider Evanston a college town, despite my opinion of it being like one of Chicago's many satellite neighborhoods. Why? If you take a nice walk down Davis or Foster, you'll notice that a clean 70% or greater of the apartments you pass are off-campus student housing. I never really liked the town itself much, but the abundance of [former] White Hen Pantries, coffee shops, and pizza joints clearly spell it out it my mind. Do you see how subjective my assessment is? </p>
<p>Personally, my favorite college town choices are these, and if you come of with a reason to counter them, I don't care because I have *** my own reasons ***</p>
<p>Collegetown, Ithaca, NY (nice town, bad weather)
University Park, PA
Princeton, NJ (home of my alma mater)
Oakland, Pittsburgh, PA
Burlington, VT
Santa Cruz, CA</p>
<p>Other college towns I didn't mention:
Missoula, MT (because the only thing there is Univ. of Montana)
Madison, WI
Charlottesville, VA
Williamsburg, VA
New Haven, CT
Hanover, NH (probably could be voted "tiniest" college town)</p>