<p>Newmtmom, I am not heavily involved in theatre except for through my son who was on the audition trail this year and has been doing theatre, voice and MT very heavily for the last 7 years. As a result, we know a lot of kids who go through this process. Also, S goes to a prep school with a strong performing arts program, and a number of kid go the audition route each year. I personally know some of the instructors who have done the University of Iowa program, and as professional writing has been a sidejob for me for years, I am very much aware of their program and people who have graduated from there. Those I know did get their undergrad degrees from other Iowa schools like Cornell, Coe and Drake. I know a few Drake graduates who feel they really got a good education there, and they are most well educated. For such a tiny school, I do not feel it is in accident that I know the number I do who have gone on to UChicago and other rigorous programs. I have seen the Drake name in several Performing Arts guides, and that is something you can research yourself. And by all means, do visit the school. </p>
<p>There is generally a pecking order in most programs, particularly competitive ones. Someone has to be the lead, there has to be "company". S has a friend at Tisch who has been "company" now for 3 years. We saw her resume on the Strawhat website, and she has not added a single credit since high school other than "company". Another young friend who is going to a less known school has so much on his resume from three years at his program that he has to eliminate his high school credits. I am not putting down Tisch in saying this as it was my son's first choice back and forth, and he was that close to applying ED there. And I would have been delighted for him to have been accepted. Frankly, what happened with him was that he had doubts about some of the schools where he was accepted. Though the programs are first rate, the school environment was not what he wanted. But do bear in mind that my son had a pretty good idea where he stood voice and audition wise with kids who are already in programs like Tisch, CMU. Soozievt, too, was in the same boat, as her very talented D had participated in programs with kids who had already gone that route. That is the advantage of being in such programs. If your kid is consistently cast as a lead, not in your highschool show, but in a program that tends to send kids on the audition programs, you can somewhat gauge where he stands. It is not 100%, and it is nervewracking, nonetheless, but you have some idea. His advisior at school has been in performing arts for 30 years and has a pretty good idea where the voice quality and music ability will place. Drama and MT is more tricky and not her forte, but she can give her opinion and comparisions. If your D does not have this kind of a background, gauging where she stand is going to be difficult. It is not the same as getting the lead in highschool or community or youth theatre performances; in order to know where you stand, you have to be with a crowd that includes a significant number of the peer group that will be auditioning. </p>
<p>The good news is that kids that come from all kinds of programs including non theatre programs, but particularly any kind of theatre program learn what they need to learn in the theatre world. Now the rest is talent, luck, contacts., fortitude..... These kids are also competing with kids with NO formal training or education but true grit, talent and determination. when you look at the broadway flyers most of the players have no credit given to a bfa, mt program or even a college. Really, the college is a safehouse for the kids to learn their art under the umbrella of a BA, BM, BFA..whatever, until they grow up a little bit. It beats hitting the streets of NYC at age 18. You meet like people, so you can pool contacts, knowledge, resources, apartments, rides. But if you look at the number of kids Tisch graduates each, year, the unemployment rate even for them is high, the underemployment rate astronomical in this field. </p>
<p>When my son looked at the program at Santa Fe, he was told that he could "own this town" as far as performing goes in 4 years. There are kids in the program who do. And an equity card earned in Santa Fe is good in NYC too. He looked there, because one of his music teachers made his break there, and still goes back regularly to Albuerquerque and Santa Fe for workshops. At Tisch, CMU, Michigan, I don't believe he would have been able to even audition for anything for a couple of years by departmental policy. </p>
<p>It is difficult to decide. I know kids who get accepted to the schools but not the program and the programs run most of the shows so the kid would be much better off in a school that doesn't have such a program. It seems clear to me that at this joinder, your D needs to work on polishing audition skills. To get the most attention, she would do best in a small school, small department where she would get the attention and opportunities. Believe me, in some of these programs, there are pecking orders and favorites, part of the trade. Which is fine, but if she really want to learn, to be taught, better she is in such an environment. The faculty seem to be uniformly good as jobs in the field of any kind are scarce and a faculty appt is a plum much sought after. </p>
<p>Your daughter is dead wrong if she really feels only the good programs are audition based. Most of the kids in S's school are ending up in nonaudition schools, albeit top academic schools. Yale is non audition. Brown is non audition. Wesleyan is non audition. Vassar is non audition. That in itself is not an issue. Where would she have applied, on an academic basis? As an English major, for instance. Some schools like Goucher, Wheaton, Kenyon have some outstanding theatre departments. So does Hartwick, Adelphi, and a number of other schools that just put their resources in theatre. College of Charleston is great for the arts. I can come up with a list of many non audition programs that are very, very good at every academic selectivity. But I would say that Drake's program is way up there, because of their fine music department, known MT dept and their long history in theatre. The drama you can get nearly anywhere if you are lucky enough to get a good teacher and program on board. The music is trickier as it needs a lot of support services to build such a dept. The advantage is that Drake has the infrastructure in place. But she does need to check it out and spend a "day in the life" . Or truly try the internship program with OW and reapply next year after hiring an audition coach to give you private audition lessons twice a week starting NOW, thru the summer, through the year. There are those who do it. Take care, newmtmom, and do let us know what you decide.</p>