<p>A few people at my school do this every year (if they aren’t accepted EA/ED by their first choice), often applying to Stanford and MIT as well. Of course, they are usually highly qualified before they do so (2350+ SAT, perfect GPA, etc.) but I don’t think it’s a wise idea, not because I expect them to be rejected by all the schools, but because a school like Brown isn’t really similar to a school like Columbia. Nevertheless, take for example 2 students at my HS who have applied to Ivies + MIT + Stanford:</p>
<p>Student 1, 3.9 GPA and 2390 SAT (school grade-deflates because it is extremely competitive): Accepted by Princeton, Dartmouth, Columbia, Penn, Cornell, waitlisted by Harvard, Yale, Brown, MIT (didn’t apply to Stanford)</p>
<p>Student 2, 4.0 GPA and 2390 SAT: Accepted by Dartmouth, Cornell, Stanford, MIT, waitlisted by Harvard, Yale, Princeton, Brown, Columbia, Penn</p>
<p>Was student 1 really qualified for Princeton but somehow wasn’t for Brown? How did student 2 get waitlisted by a few of the less selective Ivies and yet was accepted by Stanford and MIT? Overall, I think it reflects on how much admissions can be a crapshoot. A rejection letter means that they don’t want you, but you can’t determine anything from a waitlist other than that you had some bad luck. I don’t think the idea that a student is waitlisted because he/she doesn’t have ECs that are remarkable enough is true, but I do believe that a student is waitlisted because the SCHOOL needs to have certain quotas of different profiles and that a waitlist is not because of a student’s flaw, but rather because of a school’s flaw.</p>
<p>The bottomline is: even if you’re not a perfect fit at all 8 Ivies, it is not far-fetched to apply to all 8 IF YOU’RE HIGHLY QUALIFIED, because it really is a draw out of a hat for the deserving yet unhooked profile. You just can never be truly sure what a school is looking for in its applicants. Could student 2 really have guessed that she had something Dartmouth was looking for but Penn wasn’t looking for?</p>
<p>Of course, it’s wise to have safeties; both of the aforementioned students also had safeties.</p>
<p>As for myself, I will probably apply to a handful of Ivies. I am already swaying away from Brown, Cornell, Penn (if I decide that undergrad business isn’t right for me), and maybe even Yale, but I do have high interest in Harvard, Princeton, Dartmouth, and Columbia. And hey, maybe in a few years, I will be one of those students at my school who applies to all 8 Ivies.</p>