<p>OP, congrats on listening to the advice here- do you notice that you are starting to define what you are looking for a bit more? So, as woogzmama, suggests you can start re-shaping your list. </p>
<p>For example, you have now clarified what you want your uni to look like- beautiful old buildings, big old trees, not too rural, not too urban. So, cut the rural (Dartmouth, Cornell, Wake Forest, Notre Dame,) and the urban (Columbia, University of Chicago and maybe Johns Hopkins)</p>
<p>You also want studious but not ‘nerdy’ classmates, so not a hard-partying school (Dartmouth) or too serious (MIT, CalTech, Cornell).</p>
<p>You are not interested in STEM subjects, so cut CalTech and MIT.</p>
<p>You mention that you like the idea of a religious school. These offer a more structured college experience- more specifically designed curriculum, rules about student life, etc- the antithesis of Brown. So, if you like the structure of Notre Dame or Georgetown, cut Brown.</p>
<p>Do you see why people are pushing you so hard to do some homework? You might try unigo (.com)- they have pretty realistic descriptions of the colleges, and offer “similar to” suggestions that aren’t bad, and might help you focus a bit more.</p>
<p>I wonder if all the publicity about the student who got into all 8 Ivies has affected your thinking? Your SATs are higher than his, but your GPA is a LOT lower (and your ECs much weaker). Be aware that some unis will see high test scores and lower grades as signs that you are not working up to your potential- and they don’t like that.</p>
<p>If you don’t have the time to do more homework about the colleges, you don’t have the time to write all those essays! And, as another poster has said, you will have to do it in the end anyway, for the ‘why this college’ essay.</p>