Approaching the graded paper

Hi all,
I’m polishing up my application and am just about to submit the graded paper portion. Does anyone have perspective about the kind of piece Admissions Reps are looking for? I’ve got a longer History paper that demonstrates in-depth writing and argumentation, but I got some fair critiques by my teacher about the scope of my topic when it was graded. I also have an English essay that I’m considering submitting; I got 100% and am proud of it, but I’m slightly worried that the admissions rep would think I wasn’t graded harshly enough. Any perspective about the right way to approach this piece of the application would be appreciated. I also am intending to major in Political Science and my history paper is about a piece of legislation if that makes any difference.

Good luck to everyone applying for the class of '23!!

I’m in a similar boat as you. My two cents: go for the essay that is the most unique, and that demonstrates how you as a person think in a particular way. I chose to submit a satire I wrote from last year (about Juuling) that definitely wasn’t perfect with a 96 overall grade. However, everyone that I showed my drafts to found it hilarious, so my thinking is that if I can put a smile on an admissions officer’s face, that’ll hold more weight than an arbitrary grade!