<p>hunt,
I'm reading, but not agreeing with a lot of the discussion as I think that the brushes being used are just too large to be effective for a prospective student to use in the college search process. Today's college campuses have all changed greatly over the last 10-15 years by the MUCH greater numbers and types of students matriculating. This has brought more diversity, measured almost any way you like, to the vast majority of colleges across the USA. So, IMO, the "student comfort level" issue is not that big a deal except at a handful of colleges and practically none in the top ranks. </p>
<p>For example, just consider the following data on the percentages of students on the campuses of colleges ranked in the USNWR Top 50 national universities who are receiving some form of financial aid. There are certainly differences in the degree to which they have students needing Financial Aid, but it's not like these students won't be able to find others in similar circumstances at these colleges. </p>
<p>All data taken from the latest CDS available for each college. </p>
<p>% of Student Body on Fin'l Aid , College</p>
<p>70% , Case Western
63% , MIT
63% , Rensselaer
57% , U Texas
55% , Princeton
52% , NYU (06-07)
51% , Carnegie Mellon
51% , UC Irvine (03-04)
50% , Dartmouth
50% , UC Berkeley
50% , UC Davis
49% , UCLA
49% , UCSD
48% , U Michigan
46% , Stanford
46% , Vanderbilt
46% , UC Santa Barbara
46% , Penn State
45% , Brown
44% , Cornell
43% , Yale
42% , Northwestern (06-07)
42% , U Illinois
41% , Lehigh
39% , Emory (06-07)
39% , U Florida
32% , U North Carolina
32% , Georgia Tech
32% , U Washington
30% , W&M
29% , U Wisconsin (06-07)
26% , U Virginia</p>
<p>No CDS , Harvard
No CDS , U Penn
No CDS , Caltech
No CDS , Duke
No CDS , Columbia
No CDS , U Chicago
No CDS , Wash U
No CDS , Johns Hopkins
No CDS , Rice
No CDS , Notre Dame
No CDS , Georgetown
No CDS , USC
No CDS , Tufts
No CDS , Wake Forest
No CDS , Brandeis
No CDS , U Rochester
No CDS , Boston Coll
No CDS , Syracuse
No CDS , Tulane</p>
<p>However, if you believe in student quality in, student quality out (and I do), then a college's selectivity is a major differentiated part of the equation and may lead to better post-graduate professional and personal networks. There could be important differences in the types/strength of students who attend these colleges in terms of the intellectuality that they bring and the potential personal and professional connections that they can later provide. So, for me, the judgment about various college choices might be less one of "rich now" and more a question of "rich later."</p>