<p>For you football fans, i was having a debate at school on this. Thought I’d put it on here.</p>
<p>my picks (in order)</p>
<li>Favre- 2nd best in stats (for now). Most MVPs. Won a Superbowl.</li>
<li>Young- Backup most his career. But shined when put on.</li>
<li>Montana- Didn’t have the stats as Favre and Marino, but he won 4 titles.</li>
<li>Unitas- Revolutionized QB position.</li>
<li>Marino- As of now, 1st best in stats. But no Superbowl.</li>
</ol>
<ol>
<li>Joe Montana</li>
<li>Tom Brady</li>
<li>Dan Marino</li>
<li>Brett Favre</li>
</ol>
<p>i would question your #2, but i see your from mass. and i won't bother argueing.</p>
<p>:)</p>
<ol>
<li>Montana</li>
<li>Brady</li>
<li>Unitas</li>
<li>Elway</li>
<li>Starr</li>
</ol>
<p>Petyon Manning is close and going to break all of Marino's records, but I wouldn't put either of them in the top 5. Also, I don't see how Brady is going to drop from the top 5 in anyone's list of greatest quarterbacks ever.</p>
<p>Tom Brady is so unbelievably overrated.</p>
<p>Manning will be up there as soon as he wins some playoff games.</p>
<p>"Tom Brady is so unbelievably overrated."</p>
<p>I agree Brady's numbers don't necessarily scare you, but right now in a playoff game who would you rather have as your QB?</p>
<p>"Petyon Manning is close and going to break all of Marino's records"</p>
<p>why do people think this. </p>
<p>do you know how many seasons he's had over 30 TDs? 1. that was his 49 season. 1 in 8 years of playing ain't gonna get many records. add that to the fact he's gonna lose his pro bowl RB.</p>
<p>favre has done it a record 8 times. Favre is gonna break marinos TD record, and completion record and win record next season if he keeps his career pace.</p>
<p>only record mannings gonna get is maybe most career playoff loses.</p>
<p>and ace, are you kidding me at brady at 2.</p>
<p>brady isn't even the 2nd best player playing right now, let alone all time.</p>
<p>bradshaw won 4 superbowls, wheres he.</p>
<p>stats don't lie, the best 2 statistical passers ever are marino and favre.
put them on the pats they win every year.</p>
<ol>
<li>Brett Favre</li>
<li>Terry Bradshaw</li>
<li>Fran Tarkenton</li>
<li>Dan Marino</li>
<li>Joe Montana</li>
</ol>
<p>Football is a team sport. The ultimate factor in determining how good a quarterback is should be how many championships he leads his team to.</p>
<p>Tom Brady may not have the statistics that some of the other quarterback do - but he does lead his team to Super Bowls wins.</p>
<p>Dan Marino and Peyton Manning have great individual stats but they fall short when it comes to winning the big games.</p>
<p>I would take Joe Montana or Tom Brady anyday. BTW packerfan22, Bart Starr may have been before you time, but he belongs on the list with Montana and Brady.</p>
<p>"I agree Brady's numbers don't necessarily scare you, but right now in a playoff game who would you rather have as your QB?"</p>
<p>Peyton, take any of those Patriot teams that won the SB and replace Tom Brady with Peyton, just think about that one.</p>
<p>
[quote]
Peyton, take any of those Patriot teams that won the SB and replace Tom Brady with Peyton, just think about that one.
[/quote]
Yes, Peyton would find some way to choke his team to defeat. Just like he's done this year, and last year, and the year before that...</p>
<p>You mean to say that those Pats teams had better offensive players around Brady than the Colts around Manning? </p>
<p>Manning has James and Harrison, and still can't win a playoff game.</p>
<p>Brady wishes he had guys like James and Marvin Harrison around him.</p>
<p>
[quote]
"I agree Brady's numbers don't necessarily scare you, but right now in a playoff game who would you rather have as your QB?"
[/quote]
</p>
<p>Right now? Jake Delhomme FTMFW.
I don't care how the season ended for him against the Seahawks, up until then he had one of the best QB ratings in history (was it the best?) throughout the playoffs.</p>
<p>My top QB picks for a must-win game:</p>
<ol>
<li>Brady</li>
<li>Big Ben</li>
<li>Hasselbeck</li>
<li>Delhomme</li>
<li>McNabb</li>
</ol>
<p>Brady is a good QB because he makes the right plays in Bellicheck's system. I think he's good because he does what he has to do to win the game.</p>
<p>Personally, Montana and Elway are tops for me but I think Bradshaw should get a little love in this ranking also...</p>
<p>quaterbacks are only as good as the linemen they have.</p>
<p>now thats the truth. you can have the best of the best, but if thier line sucks, they will suck</p>
<p>That's true for conventional drop back pocket style quarterbacks like Drew Bledsoe. </p>
<p>But I'm not sure about scrambling QBs like Vick.</p>
<p>lol, ok u know nothing about football.</p>