For a young lady, prospective student who is very much an extrovert, vivacious and friendly, which of these two colleges do you think is a better fit and why?
Using that as a criteria, I would suspect there’s little difference. Both schools are small, expect students to engage in the classroom, and expect students to be “joiners” and “doers” in a number of areas. I know lots of kids at both schools, and although all are loyal to their institution, they seem pretty interchangeable to me. Bright, friendly, and fun.
Is she deciding for Sept 2017 and how did the admitted student events feel?
I agree with gardenstategal. Both schools were on my daughter’s list. She chose Colby in the end but I think she would have been very happy at either.