campus stabbing incident

<p>Cornell President Hunter Rawlings issues statement on campus stabbing incident</p>

<p>Contact: Simeon Moss
Phone: (607) 255-2281
<a href="mailto:sfm4@cornell.edu">sfm4@cornell.edu</a></p>

<p>FOR RELEASE: Feb. 19, 2006</p>

<p>ITHACA, N.Y. - Cornell University Interim President Hunter Rawlings issued the following statement today on the stabbing incident that took place on the Cornell campus early Saturday morning, Feb. 18, and the subsequent arrest of a Cornell student:</p>

<p>"The Cornell community is stunned to learn of the stabbing allegedly carried out by one of its students early Saturday morning on campus. We extend our heartfelt feelings of concern and support to the Union College student who was injured in the incident, and wish him a speedy and complete recovery.</p>

<p>"While we are all relieved to learn that the alleged perpetrator is in custody, the crime and the circumstances leading up to it are deeply disturbing to all of us. Now that the matter is in the hands of the judicial system, we are confident that the law enforcement authorities will conduct a thorough investigation and ensure that justice is done in this case.</p>

<p>"I have requested the Cornell University administration to monitor closely the case as facts continue to unfold and to pursue actively this matter through campus means."</p>

<p>-30-</p>

<p>| Cornell Press Office | | Chronicle Online |
©2005 Cornell University</p>

<p>This can't be good for its public image. :(</p>

<p>i can't believe this. i just don't understand.</p>

<p>this is an unfortunate event, but i hope people realize that this has happened on other college campuses/ surrounding areas.</p>

<p>every college i applied to seems to be having problems with violence lately. it really sucks. i guess i can't avoid it. or anyone else for that matter.</p>

<p>One incident shouldn't tarnish the Cornell image significantly, but it'll be bruised for a moment.</p>

<p>Any violent act on a college campus is sad to hear about, but people shouldn't fear attending the school...not because of this one incident.</p>

<p>I agree with gsp<em>silicon</em>valley.</p>

<p>Cornell is still one of the safest schools.</p>

<p>
[quote]
Fellow Cornellians,</p>

<p>This past weekend, we were stunned and outraged to learn that a visitor to Cornell had been stabbed on our campus, and that one of our students has been charged with the crime. The victim of the assault is an African American student visiting Cornell from Union College. He was hospitalized at Arnot Ogden Hospital in Elmira, NY.
We are greatly relieved that he is recovering and may be released from the hospital very soon. We extend our heartfelt feelings of concern and support to him and wish him a speedy and complete recovery.</p>

<p>Following an initial investigation into the stabbing, which occurred early Saturday morning on West Avenue, Cornell University Police arrested Nathan H. Poffenbarger, a 20 year-old Caucasian male, of
10703 Coppermine Road, Woodsboro, Md. Poffenbarger is a sophomore at Cornell University. On Sunday morning, he was arraigned on assault charges in the second degree, a class "D" felony. The Cornell University Police are working actively and closely with the Ithaca Police Department and the Office of the District Attorney. They are continuing their investigation into the case.</p>

<p>To ensure that justice is served, we urge anyone who has any information about the stabbing incident to provide it either to the police investigating the crime or the office of the District Attorney. We are all anxious to know and understand what happened as soon as possible, but officials involved must use discretion to allow proper consideration of the case.</p>

<p>We are relieved to learn that the alleged perpetrator is in custody, and we condemn the crime and the circumstances that appear to have led up to it. Violence of any sort and the presence of weapons at Cornell will not be tolerated. Now that the matter is in the hands of the local law enforcement agencies, and with the campus Judicial Administrator, we are confident that the authorities will ensure that justice is done in this case.</p>

<p>I have requested the Cornell University administration to monitor closely the case as facts continue to unfold and to pursue actively this matter through all campus means.</p>

<p>Hunter R. Rawlings
President, Cornell University

[/quote]
</p>

<p>letter to students, etc.</p>

<p>I think the fact that it was mentioned that the victim was black is retarded. it's completely irrelevant given the context and other information.</p>

<p>They mentioned that the victim is African American, and that the assailant is Caucasian. Sounds as if the article is trying to paint the case as a race/hate motivated crime.</p>

<p>yeah, really struck a nerve with me, considering they give no actual indication of motives, etc.</p>

<p>I don't want to jump to conclusions, but my first reaction was to attribute those details to cornell's overzealous diversity campaign. those stupid red arches cost $40,000. They could have outfit the entire campus housing with sweet, rain-shower showerheads for the same cost... (went to lowes on a showerhead shopping errand today, sorry:D)</p>

<p>wow. its the first time i hard something negative about cornell from you...</p>

<p>"They mentioned that the victim is African American, and that the assailant is Caucasian."</p>

<p>scary...wonder what will happen...maybe someone will stab me for being homo...or maybe spanks...for being rude...:D</p>

<p>Wait a second...I think there's more to the story than what Rawlings set out. I got this email from the Cornell Democrats list-serv:</p>

<p>"Cornell Democrats Condemn Attack</p>

<p>Ithaca, NY 2/19/06</p>

<p>The Cornell Democrats are stunned at the stabbing that occurred early on Saturday morning. We are further disturbed by the racist statements which preceded the attack. We condemn the attack and the racist sentiments allegedly made by the suspect in question. Our thoughts are with the victim at this critical time, and we wish him a full and speedy recovery.</p>

<p>The student in custody, Nathan Poffenbarger, was not a member of our club's leadership or active membership. Our organization is dedicated to the promise of racial equality as articulated by our nation's greatest progressive leaders. We hope that the Cornell community will join in us in working to create a campus where it is safe for people of all cultures and backgrounds to live and learn together without fear of another crime like this one."</p>

<p>So it looks like, judging by the fact that racial slurs were stated, that this was actually a racially-motivated act.</p>

<p>in all crimes they report gender and race of victim and prepatator. they would have said it was a white guy attack by a black man. i bet u wouldn't care if it was that way. from what trasi86 has posted it the attack may have been racially motivated.</p>

<p>"details to cornell's overzealous diversity campaign. those stupid red arches cost $40,000."-how does that pretain to a man getting stabbed?
sounds to me like: "there goes those black people again ...haven't we done enough"</p>

<p>the email i got earlier also suggested the fact that it was a hate crime. </p>

<p>such a shame too, the victim wasn't even a Cornell student ... he was visiting from Union College.</p>

<p>abike: i resent your accusation at calling me pseudo-racist. If you actually read what my post says i don't say I was *<strong><em>ed because I perceived reverse-racism (which I didn't perceive, for the record). I said I was *</em></strong>ed because I (admittedly, I now see it was incorrectly, but that doesn't make the logic bad, necessarily) attributed the inclusion of the victims race in the letter to cornell's hyper-diversity nonsense which (ready for the connection?) included those worthless diversity arches.</p>

<p>also, i didn't know anything about racial slurs or anything preceding the attack. all I knew was word of mouth "someone got stabbed" and then later, right before I posted, i got that email...but now from what I hear from you all it seems the attack WAS racially motivated.</p>

<p>As I said, I initially attributed the mention of race in the description of the incident to Cornell's overzealous diversity nonsense. My eyes actually skipped over the word caucasian until someone pointed it out in this thread much later on in time, which is why the inclusion of the african american description stuck out so much to me, and why I didn't associate the inclusion of race in the letter to the normal inclusion of race in a standard perpetrator/victim crime description. But while we're on the subject of debating my opposition to the diversity arches, here's where I stand. It's fine to say we promote diversity and that we are open to all, but I really don't feel like Cornell has a particularly huge edge over any other generally diverse campus; yes it has the edge over many less diverse (though still great schools) campuses, like Brandies for example. Yes we're very diverse here at Cornell, but it's not some magical place where everyone is 100% politically correct and completely unbiased and utterly race-blind in whom they associate with, where the membership in all the clubs mirrors the racial demographics of the student body, yadda yadda. Cornell is living in the past, a time when it was something very special to be as welcoming as Cornell is and always has been. Nowdays, though, it's just not so unusual to want blacks hispanics jews and asians attending the school. </p>

<p>That's why I feel building $40,000 of red arches in the name of "woohoo, diversity!" as a testament to the world of how diverse we are doesn't do anything "[for black people]" as you put it, or, as someone less racially aligned, like myself, would put it, "to promote diversity" . $40,000 would have gone a lot farther in other ways to help promote racial tolerance, and I honestly feel would have gone a lot farther in advancing quality of life of all students (of all races) with some small capital improvement like the nice showerheads I made an example of above.</p>

<p>It's not that I don't support diversity...i absolutely do, and I do so very strongly...it's that I think the diversity arches were utterly ineffective, and in fact a PR blunder rather than positive or even neutral move.</p>

<p>i didn't have a problem with your opinion with including race of the people involved etc. but i have a problem with you attributing the inclusion of race in the report to the diversity campaign trying to further thier position. that someway they would use this crime as leverage in thier agenda. some how a stabbing of a black man shows that the diversity campaign needs funding.</p>

<p>funny what a quick google search can come up with. he was a student government president in high school.
pic: <a href="http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/photo/2005/05/25/PH2005052501763.jpg%5B/url%5D"&gt;http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/photo/2005/05/25/PH2005052501763.jpg&lt;/a>
<a href="http://www.ccbcmd.edu/ptkawards/ptk05/poffenbarger.html%5B/url%5D"&gt;http://www.ccbcmd.edu/ptkawards/ptk05/poffenbarger.html&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p>

<p>how did the crime happen? anybody know? were they drunk, at a party,was it over a girl, or did this guy just have a psychotic breakdown? anybody know they guy or in class with him?</p>

<p>I don't know what happened...but my sister used to be in the same study group as Nathan H. Poffenbarger right before this incident. And she told me that he is a really nice guy who is studious and a reliable study partner, with everything going for him. So I think there must have been something that reeaally provoked him to harm the other student. and yes i agree it is totally ridiculous for the article to mention the victim is black and the stabber is white.</p>