Campus Visit Tour: Third Stop Williams

<p>Friday we visited Williams College during the annual summer open house held each August for prospective students. My wonderful DH good-naturedly spent his birthday traipsing around Williams on the hottest, most humid day of the year in the Berkshires. In addition to campus tours, general info sessions, and financial aid info sessions, tours were offered by faculty of the science center, music school, and the ‘62 Center, the brand-spanking new gorgeous theater complex funded by, yes, the Class of 1962. The new black box theater is absolutely cool, with state of the art digital seating…the director wants a seating arrangement, pushes the button, and the seats rotate to the proper place. Also, sample lectures were given by faculty on 3 topics: “Leonardo: The Scientist as an Artist,” “South Korea and the Strategic Balance in East Asia,” and “Sound, Music, and Perception” given by the chair of the Physics department. Only the students were permitted to attend the lectures, undoubtedly due to the large number of attendees. My D was totally charged by the physics lecture, though she commented a bit on its simplistic nature until the professor explained that it is actually a lecture given for a physics for non-science majors course. The whole day was organized beautifully and ran smoothly for the several hundred students and their families present.</p>

<p>Williams is a lovely mixture of very old and very new architecture with half of the campus straddling each side of Rte 2 in the Berkshire Mountains. The ?south (I’m LOUSY at directions) part of the campus blends directly into the very small town of Williamstown (pop 8,000). The 62 Center and an addition to the science center are new. A student center is under construction and will be finished in January 2007. Almost all student activity occurs on campus as there is little nearby except MassMoCA (the MA Museum of Contemporary Art) in nearby North Adams. Freshman may not have cars; many upperclassmen do and there is plenty of parking to accommodate the cars. The nearest large airport at Albany is 40 miles away. The adcom emphasized that Williams is first and foremost a residential college and that the students almost all stay on campus on the weekends (she noted that the dining hall serves 2000 meals/day during the week and 1950 meals/day on the weekend). Freshman housing is similar to Harvard’s with “entryways”, but Williams features “JAs”, junior advisors who live in residence instead of grad students or masters. This is an unpaid position for juniors who apparently vie competitively for the right to do this. Approx 40% juniors “go away” (the Williams term for study abroad) for one or both semesters.</p>

<p>The academic year is divided 4-1-4 and the winter month activity is mandatory. Freshmen must spend the month on campus taking one course intensively in a variety of areas, including teaching a class themselves if they desire and it is otherwise not available. Upperclassmen may spend the month anywhere in gainful activity, including as part of a semester away. The other unique feature of the Williams curriculum is the “Tutorial” modeled after the Oxford tutorial and taken advantage of by many, but not all students in their sophomore or junior year. In the tutorial, the student is paired with one other student and a professor, though the professor may have 10 to 15 total students taking the course. The student studies intensively and presents a paper every other week to the other student and the professor for critique. At times, there are lectures as part of this which more than one pair of students may attend. </p>

<p>Two students noted to us that Williams has acknowledged a weakness in their advising program that they are working on: freshmen are assigned an advisor who may or may not be in fields of their interest whose job is “to make sure you don’t make stupid schedule decisions”. There is no advisor formally for the sophomore year. Then an advisor is assigned in the student’s major when they are juniors. A senior may also have a thesis advisor for honors.</p>

<p>Strengths of the academic program appear to be art history (a huge strength...Williams is very proud that head curators at many of America’s major museums are Williams grads, and there is a masters degree offered in art history), all of the sciences, and many other fields including English, political science, Classics, and others. Weaknesses are romance languages (only 3 courses in Italian are offered, e.g.) and, arguably, music. Williams only graduates 6 to 7 total music majors each year though they do offer a performance major. They have a voice major every couple of years. Music and non-music majors may participate in the Berkshire Symphony Orchestra which performs 4 or 5 concerts a year (at Williams). Approx 25% students double major, others have a major and a concentration (minor). Theater is a popular 2nd major. Most students have MULTIPLE extracurricular activities in addition to their academic load which is acknowledged by the faculty we met to be difficult and time-consuming. 50% of the students are involved in some kind of sport in some capacity (not just intercollegiate teams, but intramural, etc), and 50% have no involvement in sports whatsoever. The students we spoke with acknowledged that those who are not on a sports team are almost all “active” in some way with running, cross-country skiing, biking, dancing, or something else. Many students are both athletes and actors or singers in either University choirs or non-university sponsored a capella groups. I will not address the issue of alcohol at Williams (a hot button issue on these boards) since I know nothing about it other than that the students we spoke with acknowledged it is present as at all college campuses, but not an important part of their social lives and noted that no student is disdained for choosing not to drink.</p>

<p>With regards to admissions/financial aid, the adcom noted that admissions are need-blind and that Williams meets 100% of demonstrated need. She told us that 45% of students receive financial aid, a surprisingly small number for a school which is, by her report, searching for low-income students who are the first generation to attend college or have only one college graduate parent. We could conclude that mostly people who apply to Williams are rich (have no demonstrable financial need), that admissions is not really need-blind, or a bit of both. She was quite upfront with her “take” on ED at Williams: approx 30% of freshmen are admitted from the ED pool. ED decisions are to admit, defer, or reject. She stated unequivocally that students deferred from the ED round are very unlikely to be admitted during the regular round since “the bar” is set equally high for both rounds, unless there are major changes in the student profile. Interviews are informational only and not used for evaluation because “they don’t predict academic success.” She encouraged students truly interested in the school to return for an overnight visit in the fall.</p>

<p>Well, that’s all I can remember for now. If I can answer questions, I’d be happy do so if and when I get internet access again. Our current hotel is having real problems. Likewise, I (and I’m sure other parents) would appreciate similar visit reports on other schools you have visited with their kids. A weekend to play, then Vassar on Monday.</p>

<p>Outstanding report! I'm just very curious what Williams is like in the winter.</p>

<p>The drive from Williams to Vassar is one of the most beautful I've ever travelled. Down the highway (7 maybe?) through Pittsfield and Lenox into Connecticut and then over through Dutchess County to Poughkeepsie.</p>

<p>I was waiting all weekend for your report. Thanks. What was your overall feeling for the school and campus? Did you love it? Did your D love it? I suspect it won't work as well for her as some others, but what was her general feeling about it?</p>

<p>Anecdotal only- We were in Williams April of 2004. Winter was still in evidence, mounds of melted snow on the street. For Californians, it wasn't the snow that was difficult, it was all the dead grass and brown plants. We only get that in the summer when the sun is shining and we are all so happy with the weather that we don't care:).</p>

<p>But in the end, for my D it was just very clear she wanted a bigger school, having gone to a 450 kid high school she wanted to try something different.</p>

<p>I have been to Williams in the winter and it is flippin cold-- but very very pretty, like a Currier & Ives print of New England.</p>

<p>Nice report, QG!</p>

<p>My son, who is definitely a humanities type, took that Physics course (The Physics of Everyday Life) and loved it. I think it's one of the appeals of Williams' distribution requirements that there are many opportunities to experiment in diverse disciplines and kids are encouraged to take chances outside of their comfort circle.</p>

<p>My son's firstyear advisor was a professor in his area of interest as he requested. He continued to interact with him sophomore year and found that all professors were very accessible for advice about their classes and others'. The lack of extensive Italian IS odd considering the number of art historians who will study abroad in Italy. The college added Arabic this year so I guess they had to make choices.</p>

<p>Fireflyscout, Williams gets a lot of snow and some fiercely cold weather. A snowy day (a week? a month?) in the Berkshires IS beautiful and because the campus is compact you don't often encounter weather related road problems. It helps if you're involved in some kind of snow-based physical activity. My son took up boarding and thrived. If you're the type that hibernates until the snow melts you're going to have a loooong winter. The same could be said of most inland New England locations. Generally, the kids dress for the cold and enjoy the snow.</p>

<p>Good point by Alumother about late winter early spring--it is perhaps the least attractive time in New England; the snow is leaving if not gone and what's left is basically mud or dead vegetation. But it makes the spring all the more beautiful when it finally arrives. Regarding the snow--in my experience and as you'd expect, Williams's maintenance staff does an excellent job of clearing paths and sidewalks of snow and ice, and Williams world continues to run smoothly in witner weather.</p>

<p>Williams was very high on my son's list....2004 HS Graduate....so we visited 3 different times to "demonstrate" interest... </p>

<p>the math department is excellent....you did not mention it, guiltguru, so I thought I would throw it out....</p>

<p>it is on the "small" side....which makes it harder to get an acceptance if you do not do ED....and ED eliminates $$ aid options....</p>

<p>if you have a child who is physically active....then Williams is a great option in addition to its excellent academics....it isn't a problem if they are not athletic, but, if your child is, then Williams will offer your kid like minded classmates....</p>

<p>the tutorial program is phenomenal......again, not for everyone, but that kind of 1 on 1 or 2 on 1 attention and depth of study is an incredible commitment to your child's academic experience. </p>

<p>the campus is beautiful... Rt 2 in the middle of the campus is a definite disadvantage. Certainly, as a driver, I hated it.....any and all pedestrians have right of way... and as a result, they don't even look.....they just cross....and it was a bit disconcerting to be looking at the beautiful buildings while driving and realize that the person who was on the side of the road was now directly in front of the car.....aaagghhh...</p>

<p>some great Asian antique stores in the small center of town... I was hopeful of a small purchase on each visit.....</p>

<p>the hotel options are weak in my opinion.......the Art Museum is stellar and a must visit ... even if you only go for 1 hour.......</p>

<p>
[quote]
some great Asian antique stores in the small center of town... I was hopeful of a small purchase on each visit.....

[/quote]
A very nice art gallery as well, run by a Williams art history graduate. I've bought several pieces from her, quite a bit more than the touristy fall foliage paintings one might expect.</p>

<p>For a music major Williams offers proximity to Tanglewood as well as Saratoga and the Marlboro Music Festival. It is an incredibly rich area, culturally speaking. Although most of the events there happen in the summer, it would be worth asking whether there is any cross-fertilization year-round, internships, performance opportunities, etc. </p>

<p>We were in the area on vacation and on one of our many visits to the Clark Art Institute my daughter, who was certain she wanted to attend an urban school for the cultural opportunities, somewhat reluctantly agreed to tour the Williams campus. After our tour, which we found very impressive, she realized that at any excellent college there will be a huge amount going on, no matter what its location.</p>

<p>Just some quick comments on quiltguru's post:</p>

<p>The formal advising system at Williams does need some work, but it's a very minor probelm--virtually all professors are eager to offer advising or just chat, so you'll get tons of advising whether or not it's from your advisor. My advisor was worthless, but I ended up getting tons of advise from several professors...advise primarily initiated by the professors rather than myself (I had one professor require me to meet over coffee with her mid-semester).</p>

<p>I can assure you that Williams is in fact entirely need-blind and fully committed to increasing the number of underprivaledged undergrads. As with many expensive elite colleges, many underprivaledged students never consider Williams because of its high price tage. In recent years, Williams has worked hard to publicize its need-blind and extremely generous financial aid policies. This, combined with its generous (even when compared with other top colleges) financial aid, has led to increased numbers of underprivaledged matriculants in recent years.</p>

<p>On the subject of music at Williams, you're correct in noting that there are few music majors at Williams. However, do not be misled into believing that this indicates a weak music department at WIlliams. The strength and breadth of music offerings at Williams exceeds that of almost any other similar college in the country. Williams is not a conservatory and it does not have a school of music. Consequentially, it's probably not the best school for a student interesting in a professional performing career. However, for a student interesting in continuing a serious musical pursuit through college, Williams' musical offerings exceed those of its peer schools.</p>

<p>Haon,
If you get a chance, could you PM me? I have something to ask you regarding Williams. Thanks,Carolyn</p>

<p>Thanks quiltguru for the update. I, like another poster, had been waiting for it. You did such a great job with the details of your visit. Really gave me a good perspective.</p>

<p>I will pass your info onto DS. He is supposed to go up for Halloween weekend, and I sure you haven given me a much better description than he will. He uses the thumbs up or down method. No details. No questions.</p>

<p>I really can't gripe about him too much! He is taking care of the house, sibs, cats, dogs, bunny and everything else in our lives so I can take his sis to college next week. He is always there when I need him. </p>

<p>Thanks again quiltguru , I really do appreciate it.</p>

<p>Kat</p>

<p>Kat,
Williams students really, really love costume parties. And Halloween is obviously the mother of all costume parties. So....I hope your son has a great time (I'm sure he will), but....It's not going to be a "typical" college weekend, I suspect. :)</p>

<p>MomofWildChild, overall, my D really liked Williams...until the tour of the music school. Although Williams has many opportunities for kids who just want to participate in music groups, the opportunities for solo performance for a kid who might want to do this for a living some day are probably too few and far between. It dropped a little lower on her list at the end of the day solely due to this.</p>

<p>So what's at the top of the list?</p>

<p>Not sure yet. 3 more schools on this tour to go. Then one or two more in September.</p>