I applied to Colgate ED this year.
SAT: 1320/1600
ACT: 30/36
Weighted GPA: 4.27/5.00
Unweighted GPA: 3.87/4.00
ECs:
Field hockey team captain
Junior council Member
Volunteer at a non-profit organization that helps animals
Officer position for UNICEF club
Officer position for Photography club
Model UN
Global scholars club
SADD club
Ski club
Stage crew
Special Olympics volunteer
Lifeguard
First chair French horn
My ACT score is technically better (it translates to a higher SAT score) but I wanted to submit both because I liked both of them. It wasn’t really something I thought about a lot.
It appears you applied to Colgate as a realistic reach. Based on your GPA and other aspects of what you have posted, you might get in. However, Colgate’s overall acceptance rate is low (25%), and, while noting you applied ED, this might serve as a reasonable figure with which to estimate your own chances.