<p>My two cents about each school (a little late, but may help others visiting the thread):</p>
<p>As a high school senior who has done extensive research on both jazz and commercial/popular music schools, I would advise against applying to Columbia College Chicago. I visited there last-minute when I was in the area, and it just didn’t seem entirely legitimate. I wouldn’t put a high value on any type of music education within an open-enrollment music school. </p>
<p>Berklee is an excellent choice. I also visited there, and it seemed much more legitimate, focused, and relevant to the modern music industry. Some classical music buffs really frown upon Berklee, but their perspective tends to be very misinformed and elitist towards classical music. Berklee is very renowned in the pop/rock/R&B/production/etc communities, and I’ve applied and scheduled my audition.</p>
<p>I just got back from an audition at USC Thornton’s Popular Music program. Theirs seems to be a little bit more competitive than most because it requires a prescreening DVD. It’s definitely worth a shot, though. The campus and weather are both amazing over there, and the Popular Music faculty members who functioned as my auditors (there were about 7) seemed very friendly, professional, and overall good people to learn from.</p>
<p>NYU’s Tisch program is definitely one to check out if the student doesn’t want to be “just a performer.” Although it technically isn’t a performance program, the Clive Davis Recorded Music program markets itself as top-notch in the realm of music business, industry/marketing, production, 20th century music history, critique, performance aesthetic, and making of hit songs. A friend of mine goes to Tisch and knows people in the program who really enjoy it. They’re learning to become entrepreneurs in their chosen field of performance.</p>
<p>I also suggest looking into University of Miami’s Creative American Music program. It combines a music business or songwriting/production major with a singer/songwriter minor. If the student writes music, I think that’d be an excellent program to look into. </p>
<p>Belmont University is of course another contender - that is, of course, if the student doesn’t mind an entirely Christian college experience. Whether the student is a Christian may or may not make a difference; what made me decide not to apply was their evangelistic nature that seems to ward off diversity. I feel that spiritual unanimity can be creatively stifling, but if the student feels differently, then by all means, apply.</p>
<p>For the record, I’m also applying to The New School for Jazz and Contemporary Music. This won’t be a good fit for the student unless (s)he’s okay with studying mostly Jazz. They do, however, have a fantastic blues ensemble.</p>
<p>Hope this helps!</p>