@brownbound7 I feel you need to raise your SAT a bit to have a good chance. Your GPA is great. Your chances will be a bit higher if you do ED at Penn given your legacy status. ED at Brown would also bump your chances a bit compared to RD, but not as much as at Penn since you don’t have legacy status. RD at both schools is a crap shoot, especially since you do not have any wow factor.
Another thing to consider is fit. Brown and Penn have many differences as schools.
I’d say chances at brown are low. Brown LOVES EC’s (from what I’ve seen in the past) and you seem to lack it. PENN (from what I’ve seen) is more stats based. Of course ECs are important but I think if you raise SAT to a 1550 and ED, you’re in.
For me personally, I applied both PENN and brown and highly regret my SAT score (low 1500’s). It didn’t seem a big deal at the time but there are kids who get 2380 (old SAT) and 1550+ who got in over me despite similar GPA and EC’s.
@theloniusmonk all ivies care about the stats Unless you’re hooked, which is often (imo) underestimated on this site. For instance, just getting a 1500 isn’t exactly enough to make you competitive if you’re unhooked (like me), so for me PERSONALLY, I think a higher SAT would’ve made me pretty competitive
You have excellent grades, below average test scores, and poor ECs. Get your scores up above like a 33ACT equivalent and write good essays. You might get into UPenn because of legacy, but Brown is a dubious proposition
If you get your test scores up and kill it on the essays, UPenn (ED) is feasible, but Brown is a reach. Your GPA looks great! What’s your intended major?
@brownbound7 A lot of misinformation going on here. Penn cares very much about GPA and extracurriculars , cares slightly less about SATs. Maybe it is more stats focused than Brown, but they do care enormously about ECs.
@Dogcat73 Of course he is not guaranteed in at Penn if he raises his SAT to 1550. Yes he has a good chance, but no one is guaranteed in not even a person with 1600. There are many top scorers that get rejected every year at Penn ED.
@agood2000 thwere is no basis in saying Penn ED is feasible while Brown is a reach. Penn takes more of its class ED but the ed pool at Penn is really competitive. Anyone who can get into Penn ED has equal or better chances of getting into Brown.
ED should be based on what school is your first choice. Penn and Brown have vast differences even though they are both ivies.