Critique my essay PLEASE HELP

Hi! Thank you for taking out the time to read this. Please read my essay and provide constructive criticism. The topic is “Describe where you live and how it has influenced you.”

A kaleidoscope of colors cascades past my eyes, brilliant azures, fiery crimsons and scarlets, vivid emeralds. Majestic elephants in satin sheaths stomp past. A massive crowd throngs the street as military contingents in regimental attire parade by. Helicopters hover, showering the crowd with blossoms. Projectiles and missiles launch, performing breath-taking aerial acrobatics. The President unfurls the Tiranga, followed by deafening applause. The Independence Day Parade evokes sentiments of unanimity and honor in the hearts of hundreds of thousands of Indians, functioning as the unifying factor between members of a myriad of castes, classes, colors, religions and political predilections.

I was born to a city of chaos, pandemonium and motion. I like to think the glimpse of vibrant saris fluttering in the breeze, kites dancing in the wind, of multifarious bodies clad with the varying hues of Holi, of marigold petals drifting past centuries old edifices, of poetic simplicity-- maybe that was how I began to perceive beauty, in natural, un-manicured experiences.

My location has had a significant impact on my personality. From the Indian morals and ethics imbibed in me since childhood, which comprise touching the feet of elders, supplicating their blessing and greeting people with a “Namaste,” meaning “I honor the light, love, peace and beauty within you, because it is also within me. In sharing these things, we are united, we are the same, we are one,” to my love for Bollywood films, and for the traditional dance forms I am devoted to, passionately spending hour after hour practicing. The Hindu gods and goddesses are revered by all, irrespective of religion. Indian culture, where a Hindu fasts alongside her Muslim friend in Ramadan, as well as attends church with her Catholic companions, is unparalleled. It has instilled a sense of tolerance and inclusiveness in me. I’m always ready to welcome a newcomer with open arms, irrespective of our differences. In a culture where guests are treated in a manner comparable to god, warmth and hospitality come naturally to me. I’m proud of my achievements, but there is also humility, as I take of my black blazer each day, deeply humbled by the impoverished children on the streets, not much older than I am, working hard to support their families, deprived of education. Their deplorable predicament motivates me to work more and more indefatigably every day, so that maybe one day, I can make a change in their lives.

The erudite and dedication of talented scientists such as CV Raman has provoked my intellectual passion and love of learning. The remarkable altruism and courage of Mahatma Gandhi has taught me to always asseverate my beliefs and motivated me to take initiative in a variety of charitable activities. Mahendra Dhoni inspires me each day to strive towards success in my sport. Rabindranath Tagore has educated me about the significant impact literature can have on society, and M. F. Husain has inspired my love of the visual arts and influenced my artistic style.

The existence of India is a demonstration of people’s capacity to exist collectively, in harmony, creating from a multitude of distinctive faiths, customs and propensities, an individual identity: Indian.

First, that was a great essay.

Second, you probably should not upload your essay to CC for a long time, because many could steal it. I would recommend dm-ing some of the well known CC posters and asking them to read your essay.

Third, I have a few comments.

I really enjoyed the first part of the essay. It draws people in immediately. However, later into the essay, it seems like you heavily used the thesaurus. Words like “asservate” and “propensities” don’t sound very natural, so consider changing those.

Also, India has obviously defined you, but I think you spend too much time talking about Indian culture rather then yourself. Just by telling them India has had an impact, you are not showing it. How did a specific indian figure influence your art? How did a specific instance with an impoverished child make you feel like you want to work hard to help them. Have you done anything thus far to help them, even just a little like giving them food?

Overall, you would be fine keeping your essay as it is, but think about how you can make it more personable if you are going to edit it more.

I don’t frequent this discussion much so I’m not sure you’re supposed to post your whole essay here. I’ll flag for a moderator to check.

I think this is a nice tribute to your culture of which you are rightfully proud. But it doesn’t tell me who YOU are. I think you could take one of the examples you give of an Indian you admire who has shaped you, and describe how that person has influenced you.

Make 90% of the essay about YOU – how does your culture (and/or this person you are weaving in) make a difference in what do you care about? why? how do you implement that in your life? Be specific. Make it personal. Reveal more about yourself.

@skieurope please could u delete my thread? I realize now that someone might copy it please delete it as soon as you can

MODERATOR’S NOTE: Per the Terms of Service: http://www.collegeconfidential.com/policies/terms-of-service. “We cannot edit or delete posts upon request; please do not ask.” Almost every person who requests this believes he or she should be the exception to the rule.

This thread - http://talk.qa.collegeconfidential.com/college-essays/1798605-the-number-1-reason-to-not-post-your-essay-here-plagiarism-checkers.html#latest - is pinned just a couple of threads above yours on the College Essays forum page.

Hey @xridax, I’m glad more and more students from India are interested in applying to PEA or PA.
What grade are u applying for as it will also be a huge factor?

I’m a junior at Phillips Exeter Academy, so I would love to assist my fellow Indian in writing the essays.
Next time please don’t post them on CC as your essay on sites like CC or Reddit will be discovered in the plagiarism search done by BS admission softwares.
You can feel free to email me with your essays if you want me to edit them or proofread at jwilliams.john4563@gmail.com.

Just relax and enjoy the application process!
And in the interview process, please be yourself, I did helped an Indian student earlier for the interview and essay luckily he got in.

OK. So a really great essay reading objectively. But it seems to much of an essay on India rather than the effect it has on you. Also, it doesn’t seem to linear. In this you discuss scientific discovery, artistic talent and sports all in one paragraph, but they seem to be giving praise to the people mentioned than to you. Another thing is that the transition is not very smooth. From the paragraph before this one to the one I mentioned above, it seems to be too big of a leap, almost as if you edited it because you ran out of space. You language is elegant but at times gets too complicated. Keep it simple in some places. Big words don’t mean big emotions. Simple is good enough.
Best of Luck. :slight_smile:

As an 8th grade student, presumably, applying to US prep boarding schools, this essay is above average in some respects & below average in at least one respect.

Clearly, you have spent a great amount of time & effort constructing this essay. While a positive, this is also a negative in that the writing lacks genuiness & fails to offer meaningful insights into who you are & how you became that person.

needs more “show” and less “tell”