<p>I think my clarification was meaningful- graduate and professional schools are different things. I also dont think I was being holier than thou when I said academic disciplines care about other things than GPA, often making the bulk of their decisions off of these. Sure, I was snide with introducing the concept of studying what you enjoy, but Im okay with that. Im sick of seeing whores who do what they want for money or because they think it will advance them in some other way. I will share my opinion that people who are acting a certain way for whatever reason are acting that way, that they should occasionally be reminded of that, and if they cant deal with it, they should change the way that they act.</p>
<p>My Thats too bad was genuine, in that it is too bad that he cannot get an A in the class, and secondarily, that its such a big deal. But really, it doesnt seem like a huge deal to him, far bigger than your post, or my post in response, should be. </p>
<p>I dont know what bball has heard in his life, if anyone has suggested to him or her that studying something enjoyable to him or her is worth more than getting into a top 15 law school. I dont think its sad- I do think that its unfortunate. I understand it, but dont encourage it, and I think that my post reflects that. Perhaps its too reprimanding, but it was fairly unexceptional in my opinion. </p>
<p>I dont think I need to ridicule or put down students for being grade-mongers. I would like to encourage them otherwise. I dont think he was asking for advice on how to get a better grade, but instead, wanted our sympathy and commiseration that he or she might get an A-. Thats fine. A good grade is only an A? If thats your belief, then fine, but that makes so many students poor, even some of the best. I think most of my posts are helpful to somebody, and at the very least, they allow me to express something. I dont think Im generally offensive, and your reaction to my couple lines in much bigger than what it deserved, but you acknowledge that. </p>
<p>I think its fine to encourage people to act certain ways, and I dont think Im being holier than thou when I say studying something you like is more rewarding than studying something for easier grades. There is some chart that one could follow, and certainly there is a point where studying something you dont enjoy is far more beneficial than studying something you enjoy- there are limited returns. But some people arent even aware of this point on the graph. </p>
<p>I dont think saying study something you enjoy is being politically correct. Be a grade-monger if you want. Its your choice. I dont think Im judgmental and didactic at every turn. If I can show some scarred little teenagers that going to some law school outside of the top three is okay, and that you can study something you love and not end up at the top five, and most people dont, then Im okay with my posts. I try not to judge intentions, but some seem fairly obvious. I dont think Im particularly noble, and Im okay with advising other people, even if I dont know them, even if they arent my kids. I dont put down everyone, and often to provide very helpful advice, do I not? Im fine with how I act in this regard, dont see myself as holier than thou, and understand the drive to get a higher grade, but will continue to do what I do.</p>