Essay about menstruation- ok?

is this topic too personal for a college essay? i thought the experience illustrated well my issues with being a math-loving girl. please comment!!!

What is a function?
My math teacher D— ------ occasionally posed this question to my tenth grade math class. A function is a set of points, I answer. The classmates’ muffled crossing legs tell my paranoia that I respond too arrogantly, and should answer instead another question: What is your function? This is a question implicit in the voice of all who see me think and love. Yes, what is your function as a woman in mathematics?
When I release myself from the voluntary confinement of Mister -------’s office, I sense mandarin oranges and Mozart. He peels and digests the oranges obsessively; I am told that when one eats too much orange food their skin turns orange, and his existence provides the elegant and muted axiom. To drown out the numbers lounging outside, he twists the dial up deftly so that we can no longer speak, or count, or divide. Instead, we communicate our proofs and logic through the strains of the maestro. When I step outside, the first feet and heart and eyes that I see ask me two small questions, through their pitter patter of difference:

Why she, why math?
The corpus callosum is a dense bridge between the right and left hemispheres of the brain. Some scientists name it intuition and provide jumbled numbers ‘explaining’ that women have larger CCs. Feminist theory tells us that we must walk this strange bridge with care, to not tread too powerfully on any one bit of reason, feeling, or intuition. As one of those ‘math girls,’ then, I view my body as a function of societal, rather than biological, differences. For example: My body as a biological entity has repeatedly informed me that I should not become a mathematician. Last May, I was told not to fret about the AP Calculus exam. In the interest of time and efficiency, then, I chose to study biology rather than calculus in the weeks leading up to the exam. In particular I memorized the letters, then the syllables, then the words: menses, progesterone, endometrial. The definitions ebbed and flowed beneath the bridges of my brain as the words did the same within the confines of my body. I have been told to memorize that estrogen is the reason why I cannot think in the same way as my male peers do. Yet because I do not want to believe that biological difference is truth, my long-term memory rejects the details of the menstrual cycle so I cheerlessly cram them once more.
So it is the morning on a day, and I sit in the back of a classroom with cool steel legs pressed against mine. The lining of my uterus began to self-deconstruct. My body had spoken and my corpus callosum responded with a weary mutter, a sorry creak. As I shuffled around the objects on my desk (pencils, calculator, mind), I wondered if there would be blood on the chair when I rose. I told myself, with whispered intent: you can never become a mediocre mathematician, because you’re fighting for the most important number—the countless girls struggling to achieve in mathematics. After, I could not move with others: I hid my back, smiling nervously and backing into a bathroom with wild intent and muddled explanation. I scrubbed away the crimson; it looked like the corpse of any mathematical prowess I had once possessed. As I splashed water on my exhausted face, my mind fought with the damsel in distress, locked deep beneath my skin. Even before I entered, the bathroom smelled like rotting mandarin oranges.

<p>Noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!</p>

<p>haha, i'll keep that in mind.</p>

<p>yea, thats gonna be awkward to read for some admission officers. but go ahead if you feel like it.</p>

<p>yeah, i figured that male admissions officers would be older and less weirded out by the subject (because of wives, etc). eek.</p>

<p>I'm not a huge fan of this essay anyways because i'm pretty confused by it, but male or female, that last paragraph is particularly uncomfortable reading</p>

<p>I just found it weird. I think that it is so very offbeat that there are only a few adcoms who will like it. If you're applying to a college known for being a haven for very individualistic, creative students, this might be exactly what they're looking for. At most colleges, though, I think the essay would be a turnoff.</p>

<p>There's also something offputting about the smell of rotten mandarin oranges. It's so strong in the essay that I keep imagining that's how you smell: Not a great impression to leave adcoms with.</p>

<p>That last paragraph is bound to give your application some funny looks.</p>

<p>Northstarmom reading your comments, I could almost smell what someone menstrating smells like, yea this is a risky topic.</p>

<p>yeah, the rotten mandarin oranges is just how the air freshener my school uses smells. but thank you, i'll make it more clear, and make the last paragraph less detailed, or something.</p>

<p>Look at it like this...if a guy wrote an essay about having to take a crap while doing math, and you were the adcom, what would you think?</p>

<p>great analogy Hoo_29!</p>

<p>This is really refreshingly 'out there', but it really is too bizarre. There are some problems with logic and some confusing parts and it needs to be edited. The rotting oranges are beyond the pale.</p>

<p>Do you really think biology is saying you shouldn't do math? You should read up on some of the findings in gender studies. I believe that males/females differ in how they learn, but not in what they can learn. I find some of your attitudes puzzling and it's confusing if these are your thoughts or others.</p>

<p>And the comment with analogy to bowel movements is way off so I'd ignore that. As you clearly see, menstration has much more complex biological and social implications.</p>

<p>this topic isn't "refreshingly out there." It's flat out weird, particularly if your admissions officer is a man. I'd like to meet one man who is interested/hooked/amused/turned-on by descriptions of menstruation.</p>

<p>Thank you Vancat. Even if it is a good idea, it is just a huge turn off. And biologically, bowel movements and menstration are COMPLETELY different, but for the content of a creative essay, they still have a gross or unattractive association. Maybe we are being unintellectual and not truly taking this essay seriously, but 90% of males are going to not enjoy this essay.</p>

<p>omg what an extreme essay</p>

<p>Wow...too much AP English for me: I thought the rotting mandarin oranges was a reference to Mister ------- eating oranges and that you were subtly saying that the androcentric restrictions placed on you as a female were "rotting" away. Guess I misinterpreted that one!</p>

<p>I think that itis kind of funny from a female point of view, but if I were reading it at a table with other admissions officers there, I can def. see where it could be uncomfortable! I would say that your writing is good but you should tone it down- a bit!</p>

<p>I just think it's too risky to use, we don't know the adcoms, who knows if they'll think it's brilliant, be digusted, find it amusing, or think it's horrible, you have to decide if it's worth the risk of rejection, personally, I like your writing, but not the topic so much</p>

<p>this is disgusting...HOW did u even think of this??</p>