Fall 07: Acceptances/Rejections

<p>There's something about hearing Harvard and Yale tossed around here that makes me want to go there, even though I know they're absolute crud for engineering. Grats to all you (mostly) physical science majors who made it there and to all the other great schools on this thread.</p>

<p>My updated list for Mechanical engineering, so far is:</p>

<p>Cornell - PhD - Accepted
UIUC - MS - Accepted
GATech - MS - Accepted
UT Austin - MS - Accepted
MIT - MS - Unknown
Stanford - MS - Unknown, though I heard someone got in.
UCLA - PhD - Unknown, though dept said they'd respond this week
Berkeley - MS - Unknown, but also heard they started responding
UCSB - PhD - Unknown</p>

<p>The only other schools I'm really waiting for are MIT and UCLA. MIT made it pretty clear they don't respond till Mid-march though, so it'll be a long wait. As it is, my top choice is probably Cornell, though it somewhat concerns me that they only have 2-3 real nano-engineering professors, and I don't want to go there and find out I have to work on something I hate for 5 years. Still, they're often listed as one of the top 5 unis for nano-research, so there must be something going on there. I guess I'll just have to wait and see how my visit weekend and MIT admissions go.</p>

<p>Anyone already finalized their decision?</p>

<p>updated:</p>

<p>Berkeley - Mat Sci - accepted
Caltech - Mech Eng - paid visit
Northwestern - Mat Sci - accepted
Brown - Mechanics of Solids - accepted
MIT - Mat Sci - n/a
*Stanford - Mat Sci - accepted
UCSB - Mat Sci - n/a</p>

<p>S only applied to 3 programs. Accepted in MSE at Cornell and Stanford. Waiting to hear on the third (interdisciplinary). (Aside to Merper: S really loves Cornell's nano program. It's going to be very hard for him to choose. :) )</p>

<p>Congrats to all you future grad students!</p>

<p>Your son is very wise. Nano is the future!</p>

<p>Either that, or I'll be back in Berkely in 5 years holding the sign: Will tune nano-motor for food.</p>

<p>what percentage of students invited for a visitation weekend are offered admission usually> i was invited for a paid trip to stanford. anyone know?</p>

<p>speaking of Caltech, i was talking to Rudolph Jaenisch and Jon King yesterday (those who are familiar with mit bio should know about them) about caltech because Jon got his PhD at caltech. Rudy had a joke. it goes like this: there is supposed to be a beautiful view (a moutain or something) outside one of the PI's office there, but because of the smog back then, he was never able to see it. so when he moved out of caltech, his old colleagues sent him a postcard with the exact view of that moutain and says in the back that "here is the view outside of your old office"....</p>

<p>and it was funny that Jon thought Caltech was a technical school of berkeley... well they didnt have a good communication as we do now, but it was pretty funny too. (no offense to any caltech people).</p>

<p>Hey merper68, has Cornell offered you any fellowship, RA or TA yet? I am still waiting to hear from them. I think I'll be offered admission but I am not so sure about money :-(
BTW, Cornell has one of the best nanofab facilities in the US. You are an ME, so I am not sure what an ME person does in nano, but for EEs it is a great place to be.</p>

<p>Cornell offered me fellowship for my first year and guaranteed GRA or GTA positions after that. I know that varies heavily between departments and between specializations though. Many of the grad students in my undergrad lab at Berkeley, applied to Cornell for biomechanics work and got rejected mainly for funding reasons(not academics as they got into stanford, caltech, berkeley etc). </p>

<p>MEs in nano do a lot of fluid and thermal work. They can also work on micro robots, nanomotors, sensors, nanophotonics - pretty much what any other major would do. I'm seeing very little distinction between nano-research projects from different majors.</p>

<p>Berkeley - Materials Sci. & Eng. - PhD - Accepted
Caltech - Materials Science - PhD - Paid Visit
Columbia - Applied Physics/Math - PhD - n/a
Harvard - Applied Physics - PhD - n/a
Michigan - Materials Sci. & Eng. - PhD - Accepted
MIT - Materials Sci. & Eng. - PhD - n/a
Northwestern - Materials Sci. & Eng. - PhD - Waitlisted
Princeton - Mech/Aero Eng. - PhD - Accepted
**Stanford - Materials Sci. & Eng. - PhD - Accepted</p>

<p>Dirt, what're you going to do about the visit weekend conflict with Berkeley?</p>

<p>
[quote]
Dirt, what're you going to do about the visit weekend conflict with Berkeley?

[/quote]
</p>

<p>I have the week off for spring break, so I'm going to go out earlier in the week for Stanford. I figured I'd make it a little vacation and spend the week in california.</p>

<p>That's what I'm hoping to do since I also have spring break that week. I just e-mailed Stanford and asked if that could be arranged.</p>

<p>Let me know what they say...I talked to one of the people I want to meet with but haven't told the department.</p>

<p>Congrats Dirt McGirt and Addwit on the MSE admits. Hey, who knows, we could be collaborating next year at Stanford ;]</p>

<p>-phpguru</p>

<p>Hey phpguru, do u have any idea when MIT, Stanford EE decisions are coming out?</p>

<p>Well I guess I'll also start listing my schools although I have not heard from any of them yet. BTW, I applied for MS/PhD in EE (VLSI/MEMS).</p>

<ol>
<li>Brown: +ve, but NA</li>
<li>Caltech: NA</li>
<li>Cornell: +ve, but NA</li>
<li>MIT: NA</li>
<li>Princeton: NA</li>
<li>Stanford: NA</li>
<li>Yale: +ve, but NA</li>
</ol>

<p>Hopefully, I'll hear from them soon. I agree that these EE departments are really slow.</p>

<p>ashfaque_cantab, nope. End of Februrary for MIT, Feb-March for Stanford. So anytime now.</p>

<p>Berkeley - Materials Sci. & Eng. - PhD - Accepted
Caltech - Materials Science - PhD - Paid Visit
**Columbia - Applied Physics/Math - PhD - Accepted
Harvard - Applied Physics - PhD - n/a
Michigan - Materials Sci. & Eng. - PhD - Accepted
MIT - Materials Sci. & Eng. - PhD - n/a
Northwestern - Materials Sci. & Eng. - PhD - Waitlisted
Princeton - Mech/Aero Eng. - PhD - Accepted
Stanford - Materials Sci. & Eng. - PhD - Accepted</p>

<p>Congrats Addwit. That is quite an impressive list of acceptances. I'm glad I'm not the one who has to choose.</p>

<p>Have any ME applicants gotten a response from UM yet? I see that UT has sent ME reponses out...</p>

<p>Yeah, I'm afraid the decision process will be quite painful. I really shouldn't have applied to so many schools...</p>