I’ll start it off.
Background: We are from the Chicago suburbs. My S has been very involved in theatre since middle school. There isn’t a PA high school in our immediate area but his HS is 4,000 kids and the acting and especially MT is very competitive and they put on professional level performances. He is in their highly regarded Jazz ensemble and Varsity Chamber choir as well. He has a principal role this spring in their musical. He has also been in many different community theatre productions and has done a professional show. He has been called back several times at prominent Chicago theaters. He has an agent in Chicago and is currently SAG eligible. (We are waiting to pay for SAG until he has a little more material for his reel.)
We decided he would apply to a handful of serious drama programs, several programs where he could do BFA Acting and keep his foot in the door for MT, a couple conservatories and some safeties. S really wanted to be in a city environment rather than a traditional campus. Really wanted a conservatory environment. We made sure to include a few schools closer to home, just in case. But we really felt like it was NYC or bust.
Applied to: Marymount Manhattan, DePaul, The New School for Drama, Rutgers, UArts, CCPA Roosevelt, UNCSA, Juilliard (definitely didn’t expect anything–just to throw the hat in the ring), Otterbein, NYU, Millikin, AADA, Neighborhood Playhouse.
Prescreens: Otterbein, New School (passed)
Accepted to: Marymount Manhattan (BFA Acting w scholarship), UArts (BFA Acting w scholarship), CCPA Roosevelt (BFA Acting w scholarship), Millikin (BFA Acting w scholarship), The New School for Drama (BFA w scholarship), AADA (Acting w scholarship), Neighborhood Playhouse (Acting)
Rejected from: Juilliard, Rutgers, UNCSA, DePaul, Otterbein, NYU
Wait-list: None
Coach @ Acting Studio Chicago
Summer Programs: Actor’s Training Center Wilmette (not widely known, but recognized in the Chicago area)
S started out at AADA audition in early fall and glad he did. The audition went well and it was nice to have an early acceptance (with a scholarship!) in case nothing else worked out. Travelled to Otterbein in December. Had heard they show a preference to students auditioning on campus and we happen to have family in the area. S was kept in the casting pool there until the bitter end. They take such a small number of students. But it wasn’t his favorite anyway because it wasn’t the big city environment that he really wanted.
January rolled around and he auditioned at Millikin. Accepted on the spot that day to BFA Acting w scholarship. Feeling pretty good, we flew to NYC to audition for Marymount Manhattan and Neighborhood Playhouse. S & I both fell in love w NP. The Marymount audition was a long group audition day. We specifically chose to audition on campus to bypass the prescreen. My S did his monologue and they did not work with him, so we weren’t sure what would happen. We really love the faculty there but they do accept a lot of kids so the competition for MainStage performance spots is tough. In the end, he was accepted to both schools and he really loves NYC.
DePaul audition on campus. S felt they barely paid attention to him. Heard afterwards from a reliable source that they were looking for diversity this year so on top of the already low acceptance rate, that was not working in his favor. No callback that day–went home disappointed.
The next 6 schools he auditioned for at Chicago Unifieds. Instead of staying in a hotel and cramming all the auditions into 2-3 days, we opted to drive back and forth from the suburbs. I’m not sure which option would be easier. Rutgers and UNCSA both went really well. Both schools asked for additional material, worked with him, had great interviews. He was really hopeful and excited about both these schools but ultimately, he wasn’t accepted to either. More disappointment. Juilliard–auditors barely paid attention to him. I don’t know if they are looking for specific things on a resume and if they don’t see them, they don’t bother. But since we are paying for the applications, I feel it would only be fair to pay attention! Didn’t really expect anything though–again, just throwing his hat in the ring. NYU–we drove to the wrong W hotel–but luckily had plenty of time to get to the right one. Again, another very positive experience. Auditor worked with him and a great interview. But ultimately not accepted. I guess the odds just weren’t in his favor. UArts also went well as did The New School. These were the last couple auditions and by this time he was pretty worn out by the whole process.
In the midst of all this, he auditioned on campus for CCPA Roosevelt, which went really well. There was a very positive vibe at the audition. We love the amazing dorms and the vintage vibe of the theatre building. I have to say it was one of the first schools he visited and I always pictured him in those dorms…
Final Decision: CCPA @ Roosevelt (with plans to do a summer program at Neighborhood Playhouse)
Best of both worlds! Funny that we thought for sure he would pick NYC but in the end he wound up back in Chicago. We realized that by staying here, he can keep his agent and his amazing vocal coach. He is already making connections in Chicago. There are no travel expenses for our family and with the scholarship, tuition seems reasonable. A couple of girls who he has performed with previously are sophomores in their MT program. He can get a BFA degree and still spend a summer at the conservatory that he loves in NY.
It was a crazy emotional rollercoaster ride, but the final decision feels smart and comfortable and right. Best wishes to everyone–it takes a lot of courage to go through this process and as competitive as we think it is going in, I believe in reality it is even more competitive than we imagine it to be.