<p>Why do you have to choose a first choice now anyway? It’s only December and you haven’t been admitted to either yet. It’s not really important to make a delimited list with a clear first, a clear second, etc. What’s more important is that you know which schools are at the top of your list. It’s clear that McGill and Fordham are both at the top; it’s ridiculous trying to force your brain to rank one higher than the other when there really is no clear reason to. Wait until April, get your acceptances, discuss the finances and other stuff with your parents, and make your decision then.</p>
<p>Also, I live in New York, and I would say McGill has a better reputation here than Fordham. Both are regarded as good schools, but McGill is better academically speaking.</p>