Gettysburg Or Bucknell? Please Help Asap!

<p>I can't decide and the deadline is Monday!! Both Colleges are very similar. I'm looking into Economics/Management/Political Science, but I don't really know what I want to do.</p>

<p>Concerns:
How do their reputations compare?
Bucknell seems to be more in the middle of no where
How are the party scenes -- I've heard the administration is becoming stricter at bucknell?
The dorms - which has better options? (I'm kinda picky)
I have the $13,500 presidential scholarship at Gettysburg. Is it worth paying full price for Bucknell?</p>

<p>Did you go to Accepted Students Day either place? I know students who are happy both places. The reputations are not far apart, with Bucknell a bit higher on USN&WReport if you buy into that. Neither is in an urban area. There are parties both places and codes of conduct at both places. G'burg dorms are nice - not fancy but perfectly nice and get really nice for upperclassmen. The faculty is accessible and the campus is beautiful. I would say go to G'burg since this is that school's thread, but if you aren't sure, then give the spot to someone on the waitlist who's dying to go there...</p>

<p>I'm a highschool senior, and I chose Bucknell over Gettysburg. I think the fact that you received that scholarship at all (I got the same one), and you didn't get one at Bucknell (neither did I) speaks for itslef--Bucknell is more selective. True, the data and numbers are very similar. However, I noticed a definite trend at my highschool that the kids being accepted to Bucknell were of a generally higher calibur than those being accepted to Gettysburg. Gettysburg seems to have rather lax admission standards, while Bucknell's admission standards are only getting tighter.
I do know that Bucknell's acceptance rate this year is lower (33% compared to Gettysburg's 41%). This number is definitely affected by the fact that Bucknell has more applicants, but this may be offset by the fact that it also has about 1000 more undergrads. You may want to compare the 2005 graduate surveys, but it's difficult to do that because only about 120 grads responded to the Gettysburg survey, whereas 95% of Bucknell's class of 2005 responded to their survey--this may say something about the unity and pride of the students, and I personally assume that the people not responding to the survey may not have acheived as much as those that did. Both surveys were impressive, but Bucknell's survey had too many awesome graduate schools listed for me to ignore.
One thing that I was told by my guidance counselor (and, of course, I cannot know for sure if this is true or exaggerated) is that Bucknell is moving up in the ranks quickly. They sent a letter to my guidance department explaining that they will be lowering their acceptance rate (to about 30%), bringing the school even closer to the ivy-leagues. This could very well be true of Gettysburg too, but I haven't heard anything. I can quote my guidance counselor as saying this: "I'm now telling my juniors not to count on getting into Bucknell." This information gave me the impression that Bucknell is becoming a real "hot commodity," and it would be a good idea to get in on the action now. None of this is completely provable, however.
Perhaps most importantly, you can always transfer from Bucknell to Gettysburg without much trouble--it is easier to transfer down than it is to transfer up. As long as you keep up your grades, you'll probably get the same scholarship to Gettysburg later on, and the schools are quite similar in size, location, and academic concentration. If you don't like Bucknell, or it's becoming too expensive and you're not getting the financial aid you need, the worst that can happen is you'll have to transfer, and Gettysburg seems to be a good bet for transfer.
Keep in mind that this is only my opinion, but I have dona A LOT of research on the subject. Good luck!</p>

<p>does it always have to be about ranking and "how close to an ivy?" rather than knowing if a school is the right fit for YOU?</p>

<p>Of course you are right in that what really matters is what makes you happy. These two schools happen to be very similar, however. For me, the decision maker was which school would help me more for graduate school. But that's just me, not necessarily anyone else. Do what makes you happy, and you will be successful either way!</p>

<p>Bucknell is an amazing school. I know for a fact that there's lots to do there because I did an overnight there and I had so much fun! Bucknell is just an awesome place. The people are wonderful.</p>

<p>Ya know, Bucknell has its own thread. This is for Gettysburg and so while I agree that Bucknell is amazing, I would argue that Gettysburg is pretty awesome, too, and there are plenty of people having fun there (though possibly not this weekend as it is serious study time with finals approaching...)</p>

<p>Well, I guess I am late jumping in on this discussion but since it's my alma mater I feel a need to defend it (perhaps it will help future prospective students). </p>

<p>Reputation wise, there isn't really that big a difference. Yes, Bucknell is ranked a little higher but frankly they are both well respected schools. According to Princeton Review, The selectivity of Bucknell is ranked as a 95 (out of 99) and Gettysburg is ranked a 94. There really isn't that huge of a difference. I have recently been interviewing for a new job and frankly, Gettysburg has been pretty widely recognized (and respected) by my interviewers. Many tell me how great a school it is. In the end however, whether or not I get a job isn't going to be because I went to a certain school, it's because of my experiences. Even people from the Ivies aren't handed jobs just because they went to an ivy, they have to earn it. </p>

<p>It is true that neither Gettysburg nor Bucknell are bustling metropolises. From what I have heard Bucknell is more so in the middle of nowhere. Gettysburg is in a rural area but it is by some major cities. Baltimore is about an hour away, Harrisburg is about 45 minutes away and Washington D.C. is about 90 minutes away. New York City is about 4 hours away. Once a semester the school will provide transportation to New York City and the students have a choice of either spending the day exploring the city or seeing a show. The school also does various trips to DC and Baltimore throughout the year.</p>

<p>Every school you go to there are going to be parties and Gettysburg is no different. Yes, there is definitely a party scene at Gettysburg but the school does a very good job of planning non-alcoholic events on weekends. Gettysburg actually has an on campus "night club" called The Attic that hold various activities throughout the year. Some of their past events include bringing in comedians, dance parties and a super bowl party. CAB (College activities Board) also plans various activities including movie nights where they will show a movie that is no longer in theaters but is not yet on DVD. They also have the Snowball which is our yearly campus wide semi-formal. CAB will bring in popular bands to campus for a concert once a year. While I was there we had Maroon 5, Guster and Good Charlotte come to campus to name a few. Every month there is also a Coffee House held in The Junction (a popular hangout spot on campus). A small band will come to perform and then after the performance it's open mic so students can showcase their recent works.</p>

<p>The Dorms at G'burg are pretty good. The freshmen dorms at Gettysburg aren't that bad. They are your typical double rooms and in general they are a pretty good size. Some freshmen dorms are better then others. Hanson, Huber and Patrick are the nicer freshman dorms but you have no say in the matter. All the dorms are very livable. The dorms get real nice as you get older. Sophomore year most students live in hotels that were converted into dorms. They are double occupancy and each room has it's own bathroom. They also all have AC. Some of the freshmen dorms do have AC but most don't. There are also some more typical dorms for sophomores. They are Musselman Hall and Stevens Hall. Once you get to junior year you get to suite type housing. A lot of the juniors will live in Apple Hall. Apple has two bedrooms (each with two person occupancy), a main living area, a kitchen and a bathroom. There is also Ice House which is very similar to Apple. There is also the Quarry Suites which some Juniors live in. These are the prized living quarters of Gettysburg College. Quarry Suites consists of four different buildings but all are very similar. They are the newest and very nice. They have a Kitchenette (but each building does have a full kitchen for the whole building). Each suite has its own bathroom. The suites are either 5 or 6 person occupancy. Some suites are all singles while others are a mix of single and double rooms. In general, however, a majority of the suites are all single rooms. There is also a complex called College Apartments. These are two floor townhouses. The upstairs consist of two bedrooms each with 2 person occupancy. Inbetween the two bedrooms is a walk in closest that connects the two bedrooms. The walk in closet is for all four residents but it is a good sized closet. Definitely enough closet space for all the occupants. I lived in it with 3 other girls and we were fine. Upstairs there is also one full bathroom. Downstairs there is a half bathroom, a full kitchen and a living room. It isn’t the most prized housing on campus but I really liked living there. Seniors typically live in the Quarry Suites and College Apartments. There is also theme housing if you and your friends want to create a theme house. You can move into Theme housing starting sophomore year. Also, the fraternities do have houses while the sororities do not. Most guys who choose to move into fraternity housing move in junior year (we don’t rush until sophomore year at Gettysburg). There is also the “Rise House” which is theme housing for substance free living. I believe you can start living in the Rise House freshman year. </p>

<p>In response to Shaneike comment about Bucknell having more respondents to the graduate survey, well Bucknell also has about 1000 more undergrads compared to Gettysburg. You are bound to get more respondents if you have a greater student body. This has nothing to do with student unity on campus. I can tell you from experience that there is a lot of pride and unity on campus. People are very proud to be Gettysburgians. In response to Gettysburg admissions being lax, nothing can be farther from the truth. Every year, admissions at Gettysburg are only getting stronger. Each year Gettysburg is getting more and more applicants and thus are turning down more and more qualified applicants. </p>

<p>"One thing that I was told by my guidance counselor (and, of course, I cannot know for sure if this is true or exaggerated) is that Bucknell is moving up in the ranks quickly. They sent a letter to my guidance department explaining that they will be lowering their acceptance rate (to about 30%), bringing the school even closer to the ivy-leagues."</p>

<p>Of course the school is going to tell your guidance counselor that! The admissions department wants to sell their school and make their school look better any way possible. They are feeding on High School students need for prestige. High School students hear that Bucknell is on the rise and thus apply and therefore Bucknell can turn down more people and thus their prestige goes up. It's like a presidential candidate saying they are the best choice for president; of course they are going to say that about themselves!</p>

<p>My one suggestion to High School students trying to decide between a couple different schools is look beyond prestige. Make a list for each school of pros and cons and try to figure out what is most important to you and which is the best fit for you. </p>

<p>If anyone has any questions about Gettysburg feel free to contact me. I can only speak from my personal experience but I will answer your questions based on my experiences.</p>

<p>Thank you 'burgian06. The info you provided was very helpful. I already sent my deposit to Gettysburg, but you gave me the reassurance that I needed.</p>

<p>Congrats on your decision and welcome to the Gettysburg Family!! Let me know if there are any more questions I can answer for you!</p>

<p>Congrats Gcorbu. You made a great decision. Best of luck in your college career, and take advantage of everything Gburg has to offer!</p>

<p>Congrats, Gcorbu - and Go, Bullets!</p>

<p>wow, many thanks to burgian06, your words are very helpful!</p>

<p>Conrats to Gcorbu, and we may meet on campus this August!</p>

<p>It has been a while since I have checked into these boards, as my son finished the process in February and is very excited to begin his experience at Gettysburg. He, too, was torn between Bucknell and Gettysburg but chose Gettysburg for the rich historical environment and great sports program that was available to him. Both Lewisburg and Gettysburg are considered "rural" but Lewisburg is very small, quaint and charming. You pass through Amish country before you get to the campus (which is beautiful, but extremely remote). Gettysburg has a much larger feel for a rural town...the history and tourism definitely make the town more bustling. The location to Baltimore and DC are definitely a strong plus. My neighbor just came back from a business trip to Gettysburg for leadership training. He stayed at the Gettysburg Inn and for four days, strategized with colonels and 4 star generals as to effective/ineffective war time strategies...all related back as to be a better leader at work...he could not stop talking about the resources and brain trust that exists at Gettysburg. I think he will have his daughter on their mailing list and she is only 10. He was excited that our son was going to such an intellectual, historical, beautiful institution. We couldn't agree more. Congratulations on your decision, and enjoy your four years!</p>

<p>... forum while looking for something else (related to Gettysburg, actually) and felt compelled to respond.</p>

<p>I'm a semi-recent graduate of Gettysburg College ('04) and I would highly recommend attending (I know you've already decided... but in case anyone is still deciding.. my advice stands... go!). Gettysburg is a great school with increasingly great opportunities for students (particularly in the sciences). I'm honestly more than a little jealous of everything they've developed since I've graduated (i.e., the neuroscience minor, the conservatory, increased study abroad opportunities, Chinese language programs, etc.).</p>

<p>I know some of you are tempted to choose a school which you perceive to have a slightly better reputation, but rest assured, Gettysburg's reputation is top-notch. I will fully admit that I took Gettysburg for granted as an undergrad and didn't truly appreciate how good of a school it was/is until I applied to medical school this past year. At the risk of sounding like a pompous tool, I interviewed at a good many of the top ten med schools (and will matriculate at one this fall) and while I went into each interview thinking initially that Gettysburg would be a liability amidst the sea of qualified candidates from Harvard, Penn, and Yale, it wasn't. In fact, my interviewers not only knew about Gettysburg, but were very impressed by it and its students/alumni. </p>

<p>Gettysburg is a great, great school... and I would whole-heartedly recommend it. With all the improvements, new majors, and increased diversity, now is a really great time to be at the 'burg. </p>

<p>If anyone has any questions regarding general life at Gettysburg, the science programs there, or being pre-med, feel free to PM me. </p>

<p>Take care and good luck with your decisions!</p>

<p>Servo - What a great user name...I just noticed it!!! Did you like the dining services that much?</p>

<p>Thanks!</p>

<p>The dining services are pretty awesome (and so are some of the people who work there), I will admit, but I just wanted a username that was uniquely Gettysburg. It was a bit of a toss-up between CUB (lame), Billy (is Billy the Bullet still even the mascot?), and Servo. </p>

<p>As far as campus dining is concerned, I think I ate more at the Bullet Hole or Ike's (which I particularly loved when eggplant parm was still on the menu).</p>