<p>Anyone pitting one school against another should have their head examined. Its okay to compare and contrast on a GENERAL level, but its not one size fits all and one man’s (woman’s) opinion is better than another. What matters is what YOU, the applicant/student feels when you visit and compare the schools for your own objectives/personality/needs/finances/social strata etc etc. PERIOD.</p>
<p>I dont agree or acquiesce to the notion that a schools value/reputation/ranking/experience is ONLY the student body. Its part of the equation…and again, that is subjective because some would rather be a big fish in a little pond and some prefer anonymity in a big school and some are more focused on programs and professors and less so on the other students. </p>
<p>If you got into both and are considering both, then visit both and decide what is best FOR YOU, based on YOUR feelings, needs etc. In a tour group you might find people who LOVE a school and others who say, “this is not me.” Its not right/wrong it just IS. </p>
<p>My kid hated Duke. Still does. Personal stuff. Not knocking Duke, its just not my kid’s thing. My kid LOVED WashU-StL and got waitlisted (like a lot of kids) and then never looked back. </p>
<p>You dance with the one who brung ya, my mom used to say! But asking people here to decide for you is barking up the wrong tree and asking us to decide which is a better school from some statistical minutiae on student SAT scores is beyond silly.</p>
<p>I know people who went to Tier III schools for SCHOLARSHIP (full ride) reasons and was way above the avg student there. They loved it and did great and got into a great grad school. That is one example. </p>
<p>I think Holy Cross is a fabulous school. But its in Worcester, not Boston. Its small. Its insular and its an LAC with no graduate programs. So its not for everybody. Its got a “Tufts Syndrome” re: BC and Williams. (and maybe Tufts, lol.) But who cares? </p>
<p>If you got in, congratulations, its a great opportunity. If you go there and visit and love it, then follow your gut. If you don’t like it, then don’t go there and move along. </p>
<p>On a larger note, our nation is in trouble right now in case you haven’t noticed. We need creative leaders who can solve problems. Not superficial narcissistic credential obsessed people who will snear at colleagues who went to a “lower ranked school.” And it may get you fired in the workplace, by the way.</p>
<p>You ask ANY employer what they want: they will tell you a hard working, creative, positive thinking, pleasant, get along, decent human being. They don’t say, “someone who went to Swarthmore instead of Harvard.”</p>