Hope for struggling students and their parents - the rest of our story

This is a post I wasn’t sure I would be writing 3 years ago. DS graduated this past weekend, with a BS in engineering from a tough Virginia Tech program – finished in 4 years, which statistically these days is a pretty big accomplishment. I’ve been breathing in and breathing out, on pins and needles, praying, for four years; it’s been a bumpy ride. I’m returning to post here to give hope and encouragement to other parents who may be facing the same sort of bumpy ride now or in the next few months: You are not the only ones. Just because your kid is floundering and struggling doesn’t mean you’ve failed and doesn’t mean they’re failures. Strap in, be honest with yourself and your student, pray, cry (but not in front of them), breathe in, breathe out, roll with it, listen, give them your perspective but don’t insist they take it, bite your tongue as necessary, hold them accountable, and don’t give up on them if they’re making forward progress, even if it is small and slow. Great growth often requires great struggle and is incredibly hard to watch.

A summary of his/our journey: Horrible first semester, all of his own making. He didn’t fail anything but came awfully close (2.1). We made the decision that since nothing changed financially and he was still in good academic standing (by the skin of his teeth), to let him continue, because that’s what he wanted. He’d dug a hole, he now had to dig himself out. He made gradual improvements, but it wasn’t like night and day improvements. Then he failed a notoriously tough class the 2nd semester of sophomore year; retook it and aced it over the summer. He took the initiative and got involved in undergrad research his junior year, spent the summer working in a lab at school for a professor, and continued working for her his senior year. Took us by surprise when he got involved in an entrepreneur challenge his senior year and went with his team to several business pitch competitions where they’ve won seed money to help move their business plan forward. He really gets and loves his technical classes and his research, even though he still struggles with grades sometimes (most semesters are 2.9 – 3.1); he lights up and will talk your ear off about what he’s learning, what he’s doing in the lab, and why it’s exciting. He got into grad school on his research prof’s recommendation because she likes his work, even though his grades are just below the normal cutoff. He’ll have to fund it himself via loans initially (he has no undergrad debt), but if he does well his first year, she’s told him she’ll fund him for half tuition next year as a TA. He’s spending this summer working in her lab, getting a jump start on his graduate research. He walked across the stage Saturday and got his degree. We went to the reception for his major afterwards and several of his professors came over to congratulate him, introduce themselves, and say nice things about him. These men had a rapport with my son that was obviously built from frequent personal interactions, not just from lecturing him in class. One of these profs was the toughest he ever had; my son struggled mightily through 3 of his classes, but reveres the man and elected to take those classes because he was interested in the material and liked his tough-as-nails-but-always-fair approach to his teaching; it was amazing to see the respect and support this man gave to my son. Lesson: struggling does not mean you are not learning and are looked down upon by the people who are teaching you.

I’m incredibly proud of how hard he’s worked, how much he’s grown, how much he’s pushed himself. He’s done things I never would have predicted at the start of this journey – some amazingly stupid, and some amazingly brilliant too. There are things about him that still frustrate me to no end, but there are also things that take my breath away. It’s all wrapped up in one package with him. I have no idea how the next few years will unfold for him, but he’s got a solid start, and he’s shown he can figure it out. We’ll hold him in our prayers always as he does.

Thank you to this forum for being a sounding board full of wisdom and encouragement when we were in the bumpiest part of his journey a few years ago. I so appreciated the hope that the stories of others who had been there, done that gave me at the time. I hope his story will be an encouragement for others going forward. It’s not always pretty, but that doesn’t mean it isn’t possible; one day at a time, one step at a time, just keep going.

Uplifting!

I love this post. Thank you for telling his (and your) story. Congratulations to you and to your son!

Thank you so much for sharing this!

Thank you for sharing… there is hope!

Thank you for sharing, Success comes in many different forms and this reads to me like a wonderful success story.

What a timely reminder that life is a journey…there is no path. Best of luck to your son in grad school!

Thank you for your story!

Wonderful!

Impressive. ^:)^

Thank you for sharing the journey and helping many parents out there. :slight_smile:

Such a great post! You deserve to feel so proud and it sounds like your son learned so much from his experience! Thanks so much for sharing.

Your post is mostly about him, but it sounds like you did a great job parenting. Congratulations!

Quote o’ the day.

Great take away from your story. Thanks for that and congrats - you all made it!

Great story – thanks for sharing.

Wonderful story and thanks so much. That said, even in cases where the story doesn’t involve finishing in 4 years and glowing recommendations from professors and so on, kids can thrive over time. And for some who are struggling in, say, a STEM area, the wise thing is to move on to another area of study. In this case, it was a determined, motivated kid and very very wise parenting that could discern that continuing on the path was the best option and the results are downright magical.

So glad to hear this story. Must remind ourselves that things can always change.

I love this post! Some folks have read my S’s story here, including the part where he dropped out senior year of a top U, then returned six years later and graduated.

The road isn’t always perfect, but parents who don’t give up on a student are what often makes the destination possible.

Congrats to you and your son!

Great job to you and your kid.

Thank you for a great story! And congrats to your son (and YOU). If we are being honest, virtually ALL of these 4-year journeys have bumps, whether academic, social, or existential. I know my S & D (proud 2018 College Grads!) both had their rough patches. It was not always easy–for them, or for us. But I don’t think it’s supposed to be. Thank you for your honest, insightful, and instructive post. And congrats again to your son.