<p>Well, it is. I just wanted to add a little more color to it by adding commentary.</p>
<p>I'm not knockin' it. Actually I hadn't read the list. I was just saying... it didn't even occur to me to put commentary.</p>
<p>yearh, i also sent the blank list. it seems as though they would have asked if they wanted commentary. for example, the fact that they have separate topics for "books that have had an impact on you" and a "list of books" seems to indicate that a list is fine.</p>
<p>not that it really matters either way, since commentary is still fine if you do it well. just thought i'd add some uselessness to the thread.</p>
<p>the supplementary essay didnt have to be on one of those topics right, since it said "possible topics"? Cuz i wrote mine on something completely differnet.</p>
<p>
[quote]
the supplementary essay didnt have to be on one of those topics right, since it said "possible topics"? Cuz i wrote mine on something completely differnet.
[/quote]
</p>
<p>Correct. There are no preset topics.</p>