<p>You asked if it would hurt rather than help if she auditions this year. I still believe that part of that question lies in first finding out which schools are willing to accept a student for early enrollment (as opposed to an early graduate) with no diploma. My guess is that fewer do that than take an early graduate (as my child was). So, let's just say that only a handful of schools will take an early admissions candidate without a diploma. So, if that is the case, do you want to limit her options of schools? Does the list of schools that will accept a student following junior year without a diploma even include her favored programs? I would not do it if it jeopardized her OPTIONS. </p>
<p>That said, I go back to my original post where I informed you that a student who is going to college after three years of high school will be scrutinized more than the typical candidate. It goes with this territory. In that regard, you seem confident that your D is ready academically, socially, and artistically, and emotionally and if so, she is an appropriate candidate. My D is entering college after her third year of high school (but with a diploma) as I mentioned but I know she was ready socially, emotionally, academically and artistically and was able to articulate that as did others who wrote on her behalf. At first, when one of her favorite schools turned her down before she heard from the others, she even questioned if she had hurt herself by not having an additional year of training cause she was younger than everyone and she wondered for a moment if this had hurt her. But that came to pass because she was admitted to five BFA programs, waitlisted at one, admitted to one school without the BFA and denied fully at just one. The outcome was positive and it appears that having one less year under her belt in terms of artistic growth did not seem to hurt her. She felt very strongly about graduating early which was completely her idea (I was not looking for her to do this as I did not want her leaving home a year earlier plus she was already a year ahead in school due to early entrance into K). But her reasons were justifiable in every area of development. Others who hear she graduated early and know her say they are not surprised in her case. </p>
<p>Only you know your child. It seems as if she is an appropriate early admit but what you must do is to call and inquire at every school if they take early admits (not early graduates) and if very few do, I'm not sure I would limit her chances to that degree by having very few schools to audition at as it is so competitive. Also, no matter IF they do take early admits, you must realize they are surely scrutinized more than typical applicants. Colleges want to feel confident that the student is ready academically, socially, and emotionally. As far as artistically, your D has to think about if she has gone as far as she thinks she can locally in her training and achievements (this was an issue for my D) and if she would benefit from going to the next step in her training or keeping the status quo. Your D needs to decide if she has exhausted the academic and artistic opportunities locally. Many factors play a part in making this decision on your end and then many factors will be weighed by the college admissions folks but ONLY if their policy in the first place takes early admits/enrollment (or in my D's case, early graduates). If your D goes this route, I think it is important that she includes a suppemental statement that addresses her rationale for early enrollment...her academic, social, and artisitic readiness, as well as has her guidance counselor speak to these. I think it is ESSENTIAL that a student not only be academically ready but SOCIALLY ready. The social development was a big piece for my child. I would not do this if it was merely an academic issue because there are other ways to accomodate an advanced/accelerated learner. </p>
<p>By the way, if you are applying for federal financial aid, your child must have a high school diploma or earn a GED. As I told you, my D won academic and/or talent scholarships at each school so it did not hurt her to be an early graduate in this regard. So, schools did NOT look down on this but I am sure they looked more closely to ascertain if she was an appropriate candidate. But again, we went into it KNOWING that the schools were willing to accept early graduates. I do not know which schools will do early enrollment. That is what you need to find out.</p>
<p>The analogy I gave you in an earlier post is still one that I think applies. I mentioned to you that when my child was evaluated for an early entrance into K, the criteria was NOT merely that she was ready along with the group older than herself. She had to be at the TOP of the group a year ahead of her. So, for early enrollment or for admitting an early graduate, a school IS going to examine the student to not just ascertain if they are ready but to feel that it is compelling. They will look closely. But if you feel your child fits the description of someone who has exhausted the high school curriculum, is socially developed beyond her age and mixes with older students and is a leader in an older age group, is independent and ready to be on her own, and has fully explored all the artistic training at the highest levels available locally, has accomplished the highest artisitc awards locally but at a younger age and so forth...in other words, is truly ready to be in the group above her and regularly is grouped with older kids academically, socially, and artistically both at school, in her training programs, and amongst peers socially, then start calling admissions to find out the policy. If they do not accept kids for early enrollment without a diploma and she has no means to earn a diploma after 11th grade, then think twice about going further. </p>
<p>I understand those that caution about a kid going off to college under 18. As a generality, I completely agree. But I do think all kids are very different and so it is hard to paint a broad brush on this issue. Many kids who are academically ready, are not socially ready. But some are. Some have functioned in an older peer group right along. It is a very individual thing. In your case, I would also get opinions from teachers in school, guidance, and her artistic teachers about her being ready to embark on college in a year. Some kids truly are. Some want to but are not. </p>
<p>Susan</p>