<p>I asked those questions because sometimes on these threads its hard to tell what kind of background a poster brings to the table. In music production, some posters WANT to study it, but haven’t yet studied it…so they’d not be good fits for the programs I mentioned, which all generally require a fairly sophisticated level of pre-college development.</p>
<p>So being able to notate one’s composition makes a difference at Umich, for example, but not necessarily Indianna, but the hands on recording experience would serve him well (and is requisite) at both. At Umich, the written composition is part of the portfolio, and is an obstacle for many “pop” musicians who don’t read or write music. With 5 years of piano, I’m guessing your guy has some theory, ability to sight read, etc.</p>
<p>In terms of “flavor,” I am only truly familiar with U Mich since that’s where my son attended. Based on your description of your son’s activities it sounds to me like a good fit. I’d be worth including on your exploration list, but so would the others. I think he would more easily get composition at UMich than Indiana because at Umich, it’s “baked in” to the degree itself, particularly in the stream they call “Curriculum B.”</p>
<p>At the same time, there’s another “portfolio flavor” at Umich that may or may not suit your son – producing an electronic instrumentation of a fugue. </p>
<p>That one sometimes stymies kids who haven’t had much classical background. The work coming out of PAT is in a wide range of genres, including popular. But lots of variety. And at some point, the kids WILL have composition profs with more western backgrounds (though many contemporary as well) and will face assignments such as a composition for string quartet, etc. that weights a little more to some western/classical experience.</p>
<p>Indiana/Jacobs does not have the same kind of portfolio elements, which sometimes appeals more to “purely contemporary” producer types. Eg. A student there when mcson was sitting in on classes said that about half of the kids in the program had “classical/orchestra” backgrounds, and half of them didn’t. The same student said he wished more of the kids had orchestra experience as it would makes some group projects and communication about same a little faster.</p>
<p>Hope that gives you a sense of flavor, but of course, please take with a grain of salt and look at all options that resonate with your son. Visits are invaluable and its totally worth sitting in on classes to get a feel for the program. Its not always practical to do that at more than a handful (mcson did that with three) but it helps.</p>
<p>Best wishes in your search!</p>