Our love for the schools that loves us is growing fast.

@straciatella @PhotographerMom Thank you for your kind and thoughtful advise. I have been thinking about them real hard last few hours, and few days. But aside my feelings from so many rejections, the logical conclusion seems is moving forward and not looking for another M10.

Small loss of better opportunities from not going into a top BS can be mitigated. She can maximize the best of what Grier offers, and also try harder for outside school Summer opportunities. On the other hand achieving the same result next M10 will emotionally painful, and god forbids, not getting any school at all with enough FA then can be disastrous to her ego.

Applying BS was a big learning experience, and it will really really and really help us in college admission later. But repeating it won’t be nearly as educational. Instead she can focus her energy in more fun and rewarding ways. Academics really don’t worry me, as dd is quite an independent learner and Grier will give her more than enough individual goal setting and attention.

Presence of international students is interesting and it will present unique opportunities if she reaches them out. As once an international student myself, I believe that they don’t always choose to be by themselves. She had taken Mandarin lessons 3 days per week for a year, and had pretty decent intonation. Perhaps she can learn it again since her Spanish is already at AP level. Chinese can synergy with her fully native Korean and 4 years studied Japanese. Grier doesn’t seem to have too many international students anyway like some other schools.

She had ridden Western for five years before switching to rock climbing. She is quite talented in riding and Grier has top notch riding program. Who knows if she might be able to make their famous varsity team?

DD’s visual art is beyond senior students level we saw at any top schools. If other students love and enjoy to make art with her, difference in their skill level doesn’t make much difference for her. The art teachers matter and there doesn’t seem to be any difference at all between Grier and other schools that she was rejected.

Once she is in there, she will be an active part of the school’s culture and strength. This is her fifth college semester and she is quite seasoned in making active small groups and even leading them for discussions and science labs. She is resilient and headstrong, which have been tested over time by some rude and uncaring community college students. She will try to make the eager to learn culture herself if necessary, instead of being pressured to act ‘cool’ if the situation arises, although it doesn’t seem that I need to worry about it.

In her Biology lab last week, her usual partner was absent and she had to join a group of unmotivated college students. She had to do all the testing and measurements while they were only writing down the data. They then immediately rushed out of class without letting her to copy the data they recorded. She had to redo half of the experiments alone while also recording, and borrow the remaining data from another group. If a boarding school’s students are nicer and more caring on their learning, she will be happy.

And as they have been, our gratitude and heart for Grier grow by every minute.

@SculptorDad with all due respect, I dont think a JBS is going to help. It wont hurt but it wont help IMO. I also get the feeling that you will be going into this as though these schools arent good enough for her and your entire rationale is this a tide over to get her into a worthy BS. While that is your choice of course I fear you may be sending her a bad message-- and what if she doesnt get in again next year or the year after? It is a lot of stress all the while sending the message that what you have isnt good enough. I dont know…

We watched all the Grier’s youtube video, read niche and other reviews, re-read the personalized admission letter, and accepted the offer with gratitude. 10 months ago we were shocked by a school far less than Grier both in academics and other offerings, and thought it would be an unbelievable luxury to attend it. Except now having a glimpse of what might be even better but didn’t want dd anyway, nothing has changed since then. This M10 is a far better outcome than we had dreamed 10 months ago, and we are very satisfied for it.

@Center, you are giving a cold objective opinion as usual, and I am grateful that it helps me to make the only logical decision. I thought about what would you say even before you posted that last comment. By the way, Grier’s acceptance was very personal that discussed their hesitation for her uniqueness but also ultimately accepting her for it. It was a very nice touch for recuperating some of her damaged self esteem.

@SculptorDad I have no problem with Grier at all! I feel concern over going there a short term fix. What if she loves it but feels she has to leave? Maybe I am confused by your plans???

@Center, the short term fix was for North Country, the JBS. If she starts at Grier then it is for full 4 years. Trying to transfer from Grier after one year did occur to my mind, as well as dd’s, but my and her conscious and loyalty prohibit otherwise. It will be unbearably awkward to ask them to help her to leave them too.

Of course she could try transferring out if Grier really doesn’t fit, which I don’t think will happen. But then it won’t be a back up since she won’t want go back to it even if she doesn’t get into any other boarding school next M10. I will never have a gut to say, “Hey, your school doesn’t fit us so please help us to transfer out, but if it fails then we will try again with you.”

And I think that - choosing 4 years at Grier over one year at North Country + next M10 is, while not being the most wished, still is most logical option I have, and is what dd wants too.

@SculptorDad AH. I missed the junior Bs thing, I was thinking you were debating both schools as a one year then transfer. On the other hand-if she doesnt like it she can still try to transfer. Sorry for the confusion. I feel bad. (The process can be exhausting and demoralizing.)

@Center please don’t feel bad. You have been very helpful.

@SculptorDad -Good luck with everything. Everything happens for a reason even if it doesnt seem like it at the time. We have had our share of disappointments and frustrations. Thats how I look beyond. The other path will present in time.

@ChoatieMom @PhotographerMom Thanks for the wise advise on JBS. They are very helpful.

By the way, we had seriously considered MBC’s PEG program which is an early college program like Bard. DD chose to apply to boarding schools instead because she wanted that type of experience. But I had honor to talk to two amazing young women and exchange emails with another who all went PEG and are highly happy and successful. It’s still an option for us to consider for 2 more years.

@SculptorDad – just curious. Sometimes you write about how emotionally impacted your daughter might take things but I wonder if it is her or perhaps it is an over-protectedness from you.

@laenen – that was a quick 3 years! ; )
We knew you couldn’t leave…

i have nothing to do except surf. time flies

@laenen, probably just me overprotecting. I don’t really know for sure.

@SculptorDad Tell your D congratulations from me! I’m sure she will love boarding school. :slight_smile:

Our son had a very bad 8th grade. He was dismissed from his all boys day school. He applied to one BS and was denied. After a year of JBS he is now
happy as a IV former at St. George’s.

@stanford94, I am glad that it turned out well for him! Some boys seem to have especially difficult brain transition period. JBS seems to have that redeeming effect.

@SculptorDad - I know you’re set on Grier but did you ever checkout Stoneleigh- Burnham? It used to be Deerfield’s “Sister School” when Deerfield was all boys ( back in the Dark Ages ). It’s still all girls and they have a nice riding program. I’ve heard some good buzz lately and I was curious if SBS was ever on your radar.

https://www.sbschool.org/

I’m amazed with the support and encouragement provided on this forum. I’ve been following this thread for a couple of days. My DS did not have his desired outcome on M10 and I’m ashamedly still reeling whereas DS and DH have regrouped and moved on.

I get SculptorDad’s OP and wish his daughter the best. My question to those who’ve done the M10 multiple times, when do you say love the school that loves you, versus, if at first you don’t succeed, try try again?