Princeton v. Yale for English Major

Posting for my daughter, so these are her pros and cons. She loves Princeton’s academic structure and resources but prefers Yale’s social structure. It’s a hard one!

Yale Pros:

Reputation for collaborative culture

A real humanities culture

Four-year residential college system

More interesting city setting

Feeds into amazing law school (if DD goes to law school)

Great theater scene

Yale Cons:

Some kids feel a need to do a lot of extracurricular activities (daughter prefers doing a few well)

36 requires courses versus 32 with research (she prefers the latter)

Good undergraduate focus but maybe not quite as good as Princeton’s

Shopping period

Princeton Pros:

Incredible creative writing department (this is a big one)

32 with research versus 36 courses

Total undergraduate focus

Boring location = kids really bond (hence alumni ties and loyalty)

Princeton Cons:

Stress culture (this is a big one)

Kids are more STEM oriented

Eating clubs fractionalize student body

Less interesting setting

Thoughts appreciated!

1 Like

Interesting…we picked up on the 36 courses too. This is the kind of detail everyone should explore.

From your lists, it would seem that Yale is your clear pick. I think the Yale house system is a big plus. No need to give in to the pressure to do a lot of EC’s, which may or may not actually exist.

The Yale senior essay is about 25 pages. The infamous Princeton senior thesis is 75-100. Perhaps that is what you were referring to in terms of higher academic stress at Princeton.

1 Like

With respect to your daughter’s intended major, she probably shouldn’t favor one of her choices over the other, particularly if she might want to write creatively herself:

In other respects, your list of pros and cons appears to represent these schools accurately, and it seems that a good decision could be made with further introspection regarding their general atmospheres.

1 Like

Thank you for reminding me - I had accidentally left out the biggest Princeton pro. Yale’s CW program is really strong, but Princeton’s is incredible.

Daughter loves the idea of a 75-page paper.

Academically Princeton is everything she wants, socially Yale is everything she wants. She doesn’t want to turn down either.

1 Like

Your daughter could comfortably choose Princeton as long as it doesn’t represent the extreme of everything socially she doesn’t want. If she thinks she would hate it socially, however, that would suffice, by itself, as a reason to choose Yale.

2 Likes

What @merc81 said.

There is a meaningful overlap between the campus cultures of the two schools, and none of the distinctions you noted have to materially affect the lived experience of any given student.

Also, while it is true that Y does like it’s own undergrads for the law school, 1) that is still only 12% of the class, 2) they are clear that they like “name-brands” and P has that in spades and 3) it is a terrible reason to turn down a program that is an especially strong fit for your actual interests for something that might someday be an interest!

It sounds as if her polarizing them into each being all-good in different things is indeed about having to actually say no to one. That is legitimately hard (and scary)- and is part of the maturing that the college process demands. The great part is that irl there is no ‘wrong’ choice here- both places will delight and disappoint her at different points (b/c that is the nature of both college & real life). Time for her to stand up and say “this is my choice” and order the t shirt!

1 Like

Check on shopping period-- I seem to recall that changes were just made (?)

Yale claims that one of its courses is equivalent to 4 semester hours ( https://studyabroad.yale.edu/get-credit ), so 36 courses = 144 semester hours at colleges that use semester hour credit systems. Since 120 semester hours is the bachelor’s degree minimum, and most colleges require 120-128 semester hours or equivalent, that means that Yale (at least in theory) requires a higher volume of credit or academic work than most colleges.

Of course, since all Yale courses are the same credit (one course = one credit), the actual workload per credit may vary more than at colleges where courses vary in amount of credit in theoretical proportion to workload.

1 Like

Doing a thesis is a pro, not a con, in my book, for any major.

Just to be clear, was referring to the OP’s mention of academic stress, not expressing a personal opinion. I know a Princeton grad who found the thesis stressful and another who found it to be one of the best academic experiences of his life.

1 Like

Thank you all for your thoughts! She’s planning on doing a lot more research - calling students, doing the online events - which should hopefully help crystallize a decision. Stanford is also an outside contender.

1 Like

What does she want to do with her degree?

Your DD sounds amazing, to have terrific acceptances in this difficult year. I’m sure there are no wrong choices

1 Like

@ucbalumnus Great math but not entirely correct. Foreign language courses are equivalent of 1.5 courses and intensive options can be 2x. Also Yale allows courses to be taken on P/F basis. There is no need or claim to fame for taking 5 fully graded courses any semester at Yale.

Shopping period is over, and frankly was a great way to check out teachers before committing to a full semester.

Yale’s student body and community culture are quite different from Princeton’s but both are academically fairly indistinguishable for undergrad. I would pick on feel and culture.

1 Like

Thank you! She is considering law, but is really pretty open.

She’s now visited both, and did notice differences in vibe. I will post once she makes a decision and thanks!

1 Like

For the decisive factor, check out Handsome Dan XIX on Instagram! Bulldogs woof, bulldogs woof, bow wow wow.

2 Likes

Referencing puppy photos is a low blow. LOL

Yale wins in the logo/marketing department!

1 Like

Top 20% of class gets to do a honors thesis in sdsu. Of department.

Seriously though, it does tell you the place does not take itself too seriously and strives to. E humane. I will never forget the look my parents got from the receptionist at the admissions office at Princeton when she heard them speaking to each other in Spanish, a bit loudly as we Latins often do, not realizing I was their child… honestly, the memory of that look was the tie breaker for me at the time.

Wouldn’t the course add and drop deadlines effectively define a shopping period even if it is not called as such?

1 Like