Recommendation Questions?

<p>I asked a my Pre- Calc and BC Calc teacher to write me a rec. She considers me to be one of the best students she ever had. However, when i asked her for a rec she said that she wants an activity sheet and a guidance counselour rec. She also said that I have to get it to her by tomorrow b/c she already has like 15 to do. I decided that I am better off not asking her to write me a rec. Any opinions?</p>

<p>My opinions:
1. You waited way too long to ask for a teacher recommendation.
2. Your teacher made a reasonable request (you're lucky she's still willing to write you a recommendation since she already has so many she's promised to do).
3. You're willing to give up an excellent recommendation because you're too lazy to get the information together tonight.</p>

<p>Honestly, by saying she has so many, I picked up on her not really wanting to do it. It's not a big deal, one teacher is already writing me one and I have another who would gladly write me a high quality recommendation</p>

<p>Of course I only know the situation from this thread, but I wouldn't take saying she has too many as a sign she did not want to do it. I have heard teachers turn down students they would love to write recs for because the student asked too late and the teacher had too many. I have also heard of teachers saying no because the teacher did not have EVERYTHING needed for the rec before 1 June of junior year. In neither case was it a reflection on the will to do the rec for someone.</p>