<p>Not a safety by any standards, but Tufts (Boston, 4800 students) has always struck me as quality, cozy, and a great educational experience. The school gets unfairly harped-upon because it's consider an "ivy-wannabe" but honestly, I think I'd rather go there than go to a lot of ivies. Admissions may or may not be easier than Chicago; it's difficult to tell.</p>
<p>I think it also depends on whether you want to go for "normal" or "quirky." For "normal," I think URochester, Carnegie Mellon (not the greatest place for an English major, but I can imagine a Chicago person liking CMU), Brandeis, Vanderbilt, Emory, Macalester and Case Western all might be possibilities. If you're okay with Cali, I would also suggest CMC or Pitzer. These are probably not safeties in the truest sense, but two of my friends who wanted Chicago and didn't get in are now at Vandy and CMU, and both of them love it. Please check out these schools on your own, though-- I'm not you and I don't know what you want in a school and what you're willing to give up.</p>
<p>If you're looking for a quirkier student body, I would suggest Reed, Oberlin, Clark, Lewis and Clark, Sarah Lawrence, Bard, and Ursinus, even Wesleyan and Vassar. With the exception of Reed and Sarah Lawrence (SLC is suburbs, but it's tantalizingly close to New York City), these are not city schools.</p>
<p>If you NEED a city and you want a safety, I would suggest Drexel (12,000 undegraduates, Philadelphia), George Washington University (9,700, D.C.), Eugene Lang College (900 students, NYC, bills itself as a rising Reed/Swarthmore), and Occidental.</p>
<p>I would also suggest looking at WashU and NYU-- especially because I know a handful of students who were given great scholarships at both of those schools and chose to come here, so I imagine that those schools warm to the Chicago type of personality.</p>