Fabulous news! Do we get to vote?? I know my favorite!
1 Like
You will after more results will come. I can guarantee that the choice will be non-trivial. You have no idea what is coming 
5 Likes
WellâŠif she gets accepted to one of the BS/MD programs, I imagine that would trump the rest of these. But Iâll be patient and wait.
Thanks for the update. Nice news for her!
3 Likes
Out of curiosity, what is your favorite so far? DD is sick of all of these essays, interviews etc.
I doubt that she will get BS/MD but she may get BS/DO. Only time will tell.
2 Likes
I would vote for Rhodes. It is about three miles from St. Judes Childrens Hospital. A great location for someone who wants to be a pediatrician.
Rhodes has excellent medical school placement and advising.
14 Likes
It is my favorite too :), except it is 12.5 hours drive + a bit dangerous Memphis and quite expensive airline tickets from DC. It is the cheapest from the list. We will go there in the middle of April for accepted students program and will see. It also has terrible reputation for campus food, and DD is a foody.
4 Likes
One of my favorite CC posters had a daughter who attended Rhodes on pretty much a full ride. She was given the opportunity to do very significant undergrad research. She definitely took advantage of their advising. She was accepted to Yale School of Medicine and did her residency at Duke. Pretty impressive!
9 Likes
Congrats. Iâm so very happy you applied to so many schools even if you donât think so. It brought you all these offers and itâs ok that thereâs a rejection and deferral. It shows you applied to the right rigor of school. If you look at CWRU rejections, theyâre rejecting and deferring kids with crazy high GPAs and SATs - like 1500.
So you brought up an interesting point later - food - and it is critical. Many of us have probably experienced kids that donât eat well, get low blood sugar and struggle. I know many chats have been on here about at Gtown, kids are spending thousands above their meal plans eating.
While there are numerous food ratings, Niche is one that gives a letter grade to all and for the most part it seems to track comments - but obviously food is also different person to person. I added dorms too.
Based on your list, they rate as such:
Itâs listed as Dorm, Food
Furman - B, A-
Hobart - C+, C-
Rhodes - C, C
Juniata - C-,C-
Just curious, why is Miami of Ohio out? Itâs B+ B+ $33K merit there is strong and would get you to a fantastic price.
You havenât applied yet but Muhlenberg - A-, A+ so likely has good food. Itâs rated 10th of 1373 so likely a good sign. And itâs a strong Hillel.
I go to Memphis for work - Rhodes is in a not great area and if she does Hillel, itâs shared with U of Memphis - you might ask where itâs held and how they get to activities.
Many schools are upgrading food because of students like your daughter - everyone is having to up their game so be sure to talk to kids about that when youâre there. But also ask each school about shadowing opportunities and look at their pre-med success.
You have affordable options - and thatâs what you were after.
As for going to Memphis, if your tuition is at your required level, then going a few times a year is just an added expense you need to account for. Hopefully itâs low enough to make up for travel expense if thatâs what you like.
I know you mentioned getting there in the afternoon on the 14th. I know you are taking the $105 flight on Frontier but donât forget, the fare on Frontier isnât the fare. I was just going to mention, while Southwest is more, the duration is shorter and if you bought a $500 giftcard on costco.com (assuming youâre a member), itâs $449.99 so in essence the published fare is 10% less. And youâd save 3-4 hours of travel time (at least on the way out).
Iâm glad your process is progressing and I think youâve done a nice job. I have a feeling Muhlenberg may be a nice fit learning about the food issue.
Thanks for keeping us updated.
3 Likes
Congratulations to your D on all of her acceptances with sufficiently generous merit aid packages! Itâs wonderful that she will have many good options to choose from. I appreciate you keeping us updated! Which schools from this list has she visited already?
5 Likes
Muhlenberg has the best food. But we are not only after food :).
I think rigor and fit are also very important. It cannot be too low or too high. I think I found (with CCâs help) good âmatchâ list. We will see results later.
DD never considered Miami of Ohio as a good fit. It was like - âWhy should I apply? It is known as a party school.â I was looking at Niche but more overall. I have to pay more attention at dorms and food but we will revisit top final list (if it is local enough). It is interesting that H&WS has so low rating, its R&B costs arm and leg.
I had no idea about Costco has airline gift cards. I can see it online now. Thanks for the idea! We may use it in the future
4 Likes
I think websites are directional. So yes, Miami has a party atmosphere but I assure you so will Furman and Rhodes and Maryland. Itâs about finding your people, your programs, your overall fit.
You have to see to know what fits right. For my daughter, Miami was FANTASTIC on paper but we got there and the ruralness threw her off. She didnât expect that.
I promise - you can find rigor at all these schools if you seek it - magazines are great for starting a list but you do need to see and feel if you can to be sure.
I canât say Muhlenberg has the best food. I can only say in regards to what a third party is saying. And you have to be careful on admitted student days - some schools gussy up the food. Ultimately, one has to decide for themselves - just like they have to decide about the campus feel and other aspects. We are not your daughter. She may go to these other schools and decide oh dang - theyâre too small!!
Keep doing what youâre doing - itâs working !!
1 Like
Thanks! We visited a lot (12 out of 20 schools that she applied). It is a bit insane, but most schools were in driving distance. We did not visit Furman, Rhodes or H&W and Miami of Ohio. We do not plan to visit Furman or H&W until we get all results (DD said no to Miami, as to Ursinus, and St. Maryâs. )Rhodes is cheapest on the list and most difficult to visit, so we had to arrange visit in advance.
5 Likes
I went to Niche and plugged GaTeh (oldest DD) out of curiosity. Dorms are ranked like C.
Sorry, if students are upset. Yes Freshman dorms are old. However, DD lives now in upper level dorm that was part of Olympic Village in 1994. There are 4 student per suite. Each student has a room, and they have 1 bathroom per 2 students, and kitchen/living room with dishwasher for their suite. If this is C, well, these students are spoiled.
4 Likes
Students are but again itâs for directional use and many schools have updated so many may stink and some may be fine. Theyâre likely skewed to first year - especially at schools where kids move off after.
Itâs a guidepost. Gives you an idea.
When you are on campus talk to kids. Thatâs the best thing to do. Abd if itâs not an admitted student day, sample the food.
1 Like
For my kids, food and dorms were never an issue. Two moved off campus junior year, two sophomore year. My kids eat EVERYTHING. As a SAHM who loves to cook, my kid expected never to eat something twice a month, they liked a huge variety and new options. Iâve looked at the niche grades for their colleges, the worst was probably a B, and according to folks on the parent pages, their kids were starving to death and needed $900 worth of grub hub offerings each month. Drama, I used to eat hamburgers sitting in hot water. Three of my kids were in hellish freshman dorms, 50 years old, two in brand new gorgeous dorms. I think the ones in the crappy dorms had more fun, itâs a bonding experience (I know it was for me). Anyway, food/dorms were never a part of my kidsâ decision making. They are also very into exercise and nutrition
2 Likes
One of the strongest and best organized graduate students in my department did his undergrad at Miami Ohio. They clearly have serious students, too. I wouldnât dismiss it just based on the reputation.
7 Likes
Every public college (and most private ones) have a reputation for being a party school.
The only way to avoid a party school is to get an online degree from U Phoenix and live in your childhood bedroom, eating dinner with the family every night.
The serious students donât get caught up in the party scene- at every single college OPâs D has applied to, there are students who are volunteering in the community, organizing symposia with professors, editing a Deanâs manuscript, attending poetry readings, working with the administration to reduce solid waste in the cafeterias, shadowing professionals in the area who have really cool jobs which may or may not be of interest long term.
Whether any particular kid gets caught up in party culture has nothing to do with the U and everything to do with the kid.
When I think of Miami I donât think of party school (Hobart has a bigger party reputation in my area). The Miami grads I know worked really hard in undergrad!
15 Likes
Every kid is different. My kid lived in the Taj Mahal of dorms and was bored and wanted out - no doors open, kids coming by, etc.
My 2nd lived in one that should be condemned and is scheduled for refurb. But she was fine.
My kid spends on food but also has a meal plan knowing that she doesnât always have time to eat.
No car - but i pay for uber to the grocery store. She wants a car - but is in a city and i wonât allow. My son has a car.
Every kid is different. But there is no question, especially at the private colleges, thereâs an arms race. Rich kids grew up at the JW Marriott and W - they want it all and colleges (even top ones those like WUSTL) are doing their best to give them the product they desire.
2 Likes
and their rep is strongâŠbtwâŠand they are known for quality of teaching.
1 Like
@tsbna44
I meant the party school reputation, according to the OP.
1 Like