<p>I'm going to put this in a new thread since putting it in my 'chances' thread seemed a little inconvenient. Obviously one's essays for Stanford are a very big part or one's application; one should be original, authentic, and passionate. I understand these general mandates as well as the concept that one should be as unique as possible. I still have some specific questions, however.
First, I'm wondering if anyone has suggestions on what would be a better essay topic wise for the stanford extracurricular essay- a somewhat quirky, humorous topic on debate culture and what it has instilled in me, or a more meaningful experience with sevice and my administrative position in Key Club (this is quite extensive, would be pretty unique) and how that has benefited some people. Both are viable I'm wondering what seems to stand out more.
Second, what's preferable in general on the essays: being authentic and unique with the risk as being seen as casual or joking, or being reflective and open with the risk of sounding prosaic.
Finally, on the picture topic essay, in your opinion would a more personal or impersonal picture-based topic be appealing. I'm kind of weighing between doing a more personal reflection on a family issue that would pretty insightful and self-reflective, versus a very jesting, satirical essay based on some of my intellectual experience and observations on society. I guess this kind of ties within my second question as well.
Thanks for your replies in advance.</p>
<p>First question: I like the sound of the debate topic...the words "quirky, humorous" sold me on that one. Second question - definitely authentic and unique. </p>
<p>But this is just because when I write, I like to be funny. Or at least a little quirky. It just makes the whole process of writing a lot easier.</p>
<ol>
<li>I think both ideas could make great essays, and there isn't a particular aspect Stanford is looking for (you hear it all the time: there is no correct answer). If you have the time, I would suggest writing both, or at least starting both, and then make up your mind when you see what you have. Since it's a short essay, it shouldn't be too difficult.</li>
</ol>
<p>Another factor to consider beyond the way the writing style is perceived is what topic needs more mention in your application. I imagine that you can explain your achievements in debate easily in the activities grid, whereas it might be harder to convey exactly what your key club leadership entails without an essay.</p>
<ol>
<li><p>If you can, I would suggest showing more than one side of you through different essays. You could have one serious and reflective essay, and another more casual and unique essay. Get the best of both worlds.</p></li>
<li><p>Put yourself in the application reader's shoes and try to make conclusions about yourself from what you might be writing. I can't really give a suggestion without knowing how you portray your family issue or your views on society. Both types of essays will work, but it just depends on how you design them.</p></li>
</ol>