<p>If you are interested in hearing and seeing an excellent concert version of Sweeney Todd, you can purchase a DVD of the San Francisco Symphony with George Hearn as Sweeny, Patti LuPone as Mrs. Lovett, Davis Gaines as Anthony, Lisa Vromen as Johanna, Neil Patrick Harris as Tobias, Victoria Clark as Lucy, and Stanford Olsen as Pirelli. The singers are all excellent. PBS featured the performance on their Great Performances series in 2001. Amazon.com:</a> Sweeney Todd in Concert: DVD: George Hearn,Patti LuPone,Neil Patrick Harris,Timothy Nolen,Davis Gaines,Lisa Vroman,Victoria Clark,John Aler,Stanford Olsen,Lonny Price</p>
<p>I pulled out my copy of Sweeney last week to hear Davis Gaines. I'd heard Mr. Gaines on Dec. 15 at a benefit performance of "Man of La Mancha" at FSU. I was curious to find out how he would sound in a different role. I had not watched Sweeney in a few years, so I did not remember the performance well. Mr. Gaines was a wonderful Anthony and he did a spectacular job as Don Quixote at FSU. (In addition to Mr. Gaines, guest artists also played the roles of Aldonza / Dulcinea and Sancho. FSU students played the supporting roles. D was tapped to play Quixote's niece, Antonia, and had a nice song feature.)</p>
<p>I made the mistake of watching the tape I made of the Sweeney performance back in 2001 the same day I went to see the new movie. Though I enjoyed the movie and I knew not to expect great singing, it was still a bit of a let down not to hear the same type of glorious singing I heard on my video. My husband, D, and I all agreed that the young boy who played Toby (Tobias) was the best singer in the cast. He totally outshone Helena Bonham Carter in their duet. I found the casting of Johanna particularly interesting. The girl who played the role had a very doll-like look about her. She did not seem quite real. Perhaps that was intentional. I did not care for her voice. The first thing that popped into my head when she opened her mouth was, "Oh my gosh! She reminds me of the warbly-voiced woman who played the title role in Disney's Snow White." </p>
<p>Did anyone else laugh when the first victim slid out of the chair and landed on his head? My family and I and most of the people in the theatre with us laughed out loud. It was just such an absurd scene! The "gore" did not bother us in the least. The blood did not look real. I thought the entire picture had a very surreal, fairy-tale like quality. It very much had the stamp of a Tim Burton picture to me.</p>
<p>I would recommend the movie to friends, but I actually much prefer the stage version of Sweeney. I hope that readers who have not had the opportunity to see a stage production of Sweeney get to see it in all of its glory soon :).</p>