By the way, here is a link to the prior list discussion the OP referenced:
I by no means think that conversation should be seen as definitely concluded, but there was information in that discussion I think provides some relevant context. In particular, this particular part stood out to me:
Again, this is definitely not ruling out colleges like Carleton eventually making the list, but I would personally suggest not letting the tail wag the dog here. Meaning just because the OP’s kid might have a good shot at getting admitted to Carleton–which I agree is true–doesn’t mean that the OP’s kid should actually want to go to Carleton.