Tear my essay apart!!

<p>IMO the essay is quite specific enough, and very good, up to the "even though he hasn't always been the perfect dad..." That's when, IMO, it starts to get a little cliched and could perhaps be edited. But the anecdotal comment about Sundays represents IMO a clear and striking memory. </p>

<p>But really, you wouldn't change ANYTHING about the relationship? This seems harsh, in that it implies that you Dad's alcoholism, though harmful to him, is worthwhile because of its pedagogical effect on you. I think you can recognize the lesson without saying something that, IMO, streches credulity.</p>

<p>AAAHHHH!! sorry...needed to let a little stress out. So...here's what I'm struggling with, you've all been so helpful so far maybe you have some tips. ADad, you're comment about how it starts getting cliched towards the end, I don't have any clue how to make it better. No ideas. None. I really want to finish this essay. I changed a few of the cliches you guys mentioned all ready. The "grain of salt" comment is gone. And ADad, you're right about how i wouldn't not change anything about my relationship with my dad. I took that line out and replaced it with something else. All i need now is to revamp my last paragraph. I know it's too general and broad and cliche, but anyone have any ideas about what I could do with it????</p>

<p>Okay, so after a lot of hard work yesterday, I finally rewrote parts of my essay, taking into consideration what all of you said. For those of you who have already read it, don't think you shouldn't read it again because it will be the same with a few different words. It's not. I decided to completely rewrite three of the five paragraphs and I'm curious to see whether you guys think I made the essay better or worse. Here it goes....</p>

<p>“Kirkuk suicide blast kills 19."
My heart dropped, my head spun, and shivers ran down my spine. One word from a stranger on television and I felt like I’d been punched in the stomach. For the millions of other people watching this story, it meant nothing, but for me, those five words had the ability to turn my life upside down. That’s what it was like for the six months my dad was in Kirkuk, Iraq. Every time the city was mentioned on the news, I froze, hoping that it was someone else and not my dad. I prayed every night that he would return safely and every time there was a report on the news that a soldier had been killed in a bomb blast in Kirkuk, I held my breath until I heard from him.
I never would have imagined that the absence of my dad would affect me as much as it did. Because of my parent’s divorce and my dad’s drinking problem we had never been as close as we could have been. When I was a little girl I didn’t realize that my dad even had a drinking problem. I found out by mistake, when my mom picked me up from my dad’s house one Sunday afternoon when I was seven. He walked me out to the car to say goodbye and as we were driving away, my mom asked me if he was drunk again. I could tell by the look on her face as she saw the look on mine that she knew she had made a mistake. All my life my mom had been the one to make up for the absence of my dad. When he forgot my birthday she would make excuses for him and when I cried because he never told me he loved me, she always reassured me that he did. But her mistaken words in the car that day finally provided me with the explanation I had been searching for my entire life to explain my dad’s behavior. In a way it was a relief, but at the same time an added burden. As we grew more and more distant and his interest in my life dwindled, I wished that he would just disappear. I can honestly say that for the greater part of my childhood I didn’t love my own father.
However, all of that changed one Sunday afternoon, when for the first time in quite a while, my dad actually started talking to me. Really talking to me, not just one of our typical ‘how’s school’ conversations. But the words he was saying made no sense. Iraq. Leaving in September. I’m Sorry. I love you. What? I had imagined my dad apologizing to me and telling me he loved me for a very long time, practically all my life, but I had never imagined it being like this. The first thought that came to my mind was that he was exaggerating, another one of his habits that made me lose my respect for him. But the one time that I wanted what he told me to be an exaggeration, it wasn’t. It was actually the truth.
That September, as I began my Junior year in high school, I also said goodbye to my dad. As my friends thought about what they would wear the first day of school or how hard the classes would be, I thought about whether or not I would ever see my dad again. Suddenly Sundays, the same Sundays I had despised as a little girl because I had to go to my dad’s house, became unbearable because I couldn’t go to my dad’s house. As the fact that he really wasn’t here sank in, I realized how much I really do need him. Looking back, it seems ironic that it took a war to bring us closer together.
When my dad came home, safe, and held me in his arms, I realized that on some level he really does love me. He may not show his love like other dads, but that doesn’t mean that it doesn’t exist. While my dad hasn’t changed much since he came home, I have. All those years I spent despising having to go to his house actually ended up teaching me one of the most important lessons I have ever learned. Today, instead of hating my dad because of his drinking problem and wondering why he couldn’t be more like other dads, I’ve learned to simply accept him the way he is, imperfections and all. Of course I worry about the effect that his drinking will have on his health, but at the same time I realize that when he’s ready to change, he will. Having to accept my dad for who he is, not who I wish he was, has been hard, but it has prepared me, more than anything else, for what life will really be like.</p>

<p>"Every time the city was mentioned on the news, I froze, hoping that it was someone else, anyone else, just not my dad."</p>

<p>I think the original sentence shows your desperation more clearly, but either way, that sentence is out of character. Your first paragraph shocked me at first because it gives off the impression that as long as your dad is fine, you don't care about the 19 people and other soldiers in Iraq like "the millions of other people watching this story, [to whom the story] meant nothing." You should add something about respecting people in Iraq in general, not just your dad.</p>

<p>Good improvement and as Uhh said you should show respect for other Iraqis (me included :D)</p>

<p>Leave it as is. Change nothing.</p>

<p>Good points osmosis and uhhh. I'll try to see if I can reword things to make it more abvious that I do care about other people than my dad, because i really do.
So did everyone like this version more than the first or is it worse??</p>