<p>Caleno-Obviously what you went through at school was horrible, however you misread my post-where I clearly said I think that approach was, and is, terribly wrong. But I do think your housemaster's response was part of a "playing fields of Eton" mentality generally prevelent at the time. My uncle clearly got the same message you did as a result of the same kind of bullying, and in his case it turned out all right. Maybe the "streets of Trenton" were better preparation for Lawrenceville than everyone thought at the time. I'm not saying that was good-it's just the way it was.</p>
<p>For the record my father in law is a holocaust survivor, so I am well aware of just how terrible anti semitism can be, and not as naive as you may think I am . I've taught both in the inner city and at an independent school, and been involved in diversity issues at my daughter's school for the last seven years. Racism is a regretable fact of life everywhere there are humans, but I do think many independent schools are making a concerted push to change the climate for all students.</p>
<p>Your comments make the idea of an overnight visit and conversations with minority alums and families even more desirable for the OP's daughter. They are far more in touch with the current climate at the school than either of us are. The admissions office should be able to put the OP in touch with them. </p>
<p>I think what happened to you is unconscionable, but I also think it was part of an overall attitude prevelent at many boys' boarding schools of the time: that boys should fight their own battles. That something or someone was a product of their times doesn't make something like what you went through right, but it does suggest the possibilty of change. These schools offer the best education you can give your children. Because of that I've found pushing for change and holding our school to a high standard, a worthwhile thing to do. If we avoid these institutions entirely we are only allowing the racists and anti semites to win.</p>
<p>My experience with Lawrenceville is decades old and second hand. My experience with Andover is more recent and direct, and their efforts have been impressive. My experiences with independent schools, as a student, teacher. and parent, is that people choose them for two reasons, one is for the exclusivity/country club aspect-these are going to be where you find your pockets of regretable values and attitudes. The other reason to choose these schools is for the incomparable education. At PDS I found my closest friends among the intellectuals of my class, that was why I was there and the school didn't let me down. At every independent school, especially one of Lawrenceville's caliber, there are going to be really amazing kids for whom the intellectual life of the school is what really matters. My personal experience is that race and class don't count for much among those kids.</p>
<p>I just got back from breakfast with the diversity officer of our school, where we were discussing a lot of these same issues. Personally I'm convinced that endeavering to gain cultural literacy and combat racist and anti semitic attitudes wherever we find them, including in our own hearts, is an on going struggle. If we are really honest with ourselves, no community, including the Jewish community, and certainly not the Italian American community, is immune to racism and hubris. Despite what our parents and grandparents went through, we are still not perfect. Despite all the changes we went through in the 60s we are still not perfect. My work has put me in collaborative relationships with varous minority communities-even within these minority communities there isn't perfect tolerance for other minorities. This work of changing attitudes and staying open to others is something all people of good will have to attend to every day. I don't know where Lawrenceville is on the continuum of cultural literacy and good vibes. I do think it is something they are working on. These discussion forums are valuable because they allow for a real dialogue among people who have had different experiences. </p>
<p>I'm really sorry you had to go through what you went through. My own experience was the opposite; my public school is where I was chased home by the pack of bullies calling me a WOP; my public school is where I had to endure the endlessly offensive Italian jokes; PDS is where I was finally able to be myself. Interestingly-it was only my wealthy (male) Jewish classmates from Trenton who teased me about being Italian at PDS. Maybe I was a tempting target for their teasing because they saw me as one step down in the ethnic pecking order from them. They were friends, and I was able to laugh it off, but it still stung. My point is-no person or place is immune to this kind of bullying and tribalism, especially among adolescents.</p>