<p>I am LOVING this thread! I love reading every opinion expressed here. However, IMHO, I don’t feel the Greek/Independent issue is quite as easily navigated as some (especially those not raised in the South) might think. I have two sons. One is a proud STEM geek with super-high stats who his friends describe as “Sheldon with social skills” (Big Bang reference, of course). The other is a glad-handing good ol’ boy who will have decent, well-above average stats (but probably not NMF), will most likely major in the humanities or communications, and probably has a future in politics. Two very different kids–both interested in Bama (the younger even more so than the olderRABID Bama fan, the DS2 is). I am a Southern “sorority girl”, raising my children far from the South (married someone from far away and, somehow, it never occurred to me that I would end up living here. LOL) Anyway, my children are interested in Bama, but have little current interest in being Greek. Like many of your children, if they go to Bama, they will be OOS and probably both in Honors programs at varying levels. There is so much support for the OOS Honors kids now! Its almost overwhelming the environment theyve created over the past decade. So, up to the point where they are OOS/Honors/Indies, I’m with you. The OOS/Honors/Indies experience is amazing. </p>
<p>However, here’s where I have to diverge and say I also agree with NBC. Even though my kids look on paper like they are OOS/Honors/Indies-in-the-making, it’s more complicated than that. Without going into great detail, shall we simply summarize by saying that they are…ummm… “culturally Southern”? In other words, most OOS/Honors/Independents dont have to worry about whether they will see their long-time friends/family members on campus. Or whether they can hang out with their old friends on the weekends. Or whether they can go to parties or football games together if they dont have a date. Or whether that friend they have known since infancy but who lived thousands of miles away might potentially turn into something more than a friend once they are on the same college campus. Few OOS (and by OOS, I mean out-of the DeepSouth, as many kids from surrounding states go to Bama with other friends from home) students have friends from home on campus with them. While it is highly unlikely that my kids would have friends from home at UA, they will have dozens of friends and family members on campus while they are there. These are kids they have spent summers and holidays with since they were born. And every single one of those kids will be Greek. </p>
<p>I dont worry much about my older son. He could go Greek, or not. Wont matter. He is much more interested in intellectual pursuits than matters of social status. He makes his own fun (though I usually dont understand its premise and probably cant pronounce its major components). Im more worried about my younger son. Though hes a good student and will probably qualify for Honors if he goes to UA, he identifies much more with the Greeks than the Geeks. If he goes to Bama, he will arrive there with a cohort of Southern female friends, all of whom have been talking to him about UA fraternities since middle school. As of yesterday, he has no interest in fraternities (I HATE the smell of spilled beer! And I hate cigarette smoke even more. If I had to clean up after a party, Id barf. Then Id go home and I wouldnt care if they kicked me out or not.) No, fraternity life doesnt look promising for him
haha. However, if he does not pledge, he WILL be cut off socially from kids with whom he has grown up and, in some cases, shares a bloodline (something I havent really discussed with him yet). As OOS kids from 2000 miles away, my kids are clueless about the strong separations between Greeks and Non-Greeks at the UA. It doesn’t happen here where the Greek community is small. If they weren’t going to have friends and family on campus, they would be blissfully unaware that anything was amiss, just as most of your children are. However, for Southern-born and “culturally Southern” kids who fit the Greek profile, but choose for whatever reason not to pledge, I do believe that there are issues that need to be thought out before deciding to move to T-Town.</p>
<p>My kids aren’t anti-Greek, at all. They wear my party shirts from the '80’s. They know what a rec is (I have to write them every summer). They were addicted to “Greek”. LOL. They simply dont want to clean up beersoaked party rooms or get hazed. Since it’s their impression that both are part of pledgeship, they have no interest in rushing.</p>
<p>On one hand, I love the fact that they dont party. At their school, its just as cool to be smart and clean as it is to be a party animal. Theres a lot of crossover, and whether you go to parties, drink, smoke, etc. doesnt affect your popularity one way or the other. On the other hand, DS2 always wants to be in the middle of everything, and would be heartbroken if this group of kids he has spent summers and holidays with his entire life suddenly couldnt be seen with him because he wasnt wearing a pledge pin. I want to believe that there has been progress on the partying/hazing similar to the great strides on the Indie/Honors front. However, I havent seen evidence that is the case. Both of my kids are leaders-- happy-go-lucky, friendly, confident scholars. They arent judgmental, dont care what other people do, and are friends with many of the partiers at their school. However, they simply dont choose to party. I remember guys like them being in fraternities in college. But they were few in number. I think I remember three, and one was a football player. Not very good odds.</p>
<p>So, I continue to grapple with whether Bama is a good fit for my kids for myriad reasons. Right now, I feel like its a better social fit for my older son than my younger, though its my younger son who lives and breathes Bama! However, it wasn’t long ago that I wasn’t sure it was a good fit for either of them. Reading everyone elses experiences is SO helpful and enlightening. Keep it up! There are a lot of us out here who are more lurker than poster who want and need to hear ALL perspectives. And, NBC, I know of what you speak. Some things NEVER change but, fortunately, a few do. Its trying to figure out the levels and degrees of change and acceptance that gets tricky. ;)</p>